A one-warehouse multi-retailer (OWMR) system is a two-echelon distribution network: a warehouse buys from an outside supplier and ships to several retailers, each facing random demand. Fixed costs per supplier order and per retailer shipment favor large, infrequent orders; holding and backlog costs favor small, frequent ones; and lead times at both echelons keep the two levels from acting together. Such systems model retail chains that replenish stores from a distribution center.
For distribution systems with fixed costs at both echelons, no tractable optimal policy is known. Earlier work optimizes within a restricted policy class or gives bounds that become tight only in a limit; constant-factor approximations are known for deterministic demand.
Timeline.
Retailers are indexed by and periods by . In each period, scheduled shipments arrive; the warehouse may place a supplier order , which arrives in period ; it may dispatch to retailer , which arrives in period ; then demand occurs and is met from retailer stock or backlogged. The lead times are finite nonnegative integers. The demand vectors are i.i.d. over periods with nonnegative components and ; demands of different retailers in one period may be dependent. With warehouse stock , retailer net inventories , setup costs , holding rates , and a common backlog penalty , the period cost is
A policy is nonanticipative if its decisions use only the observed history and auxiliary randomness independent of all demands, and feasible if its orders and dispatches are nonnegative and its dispatches never exceed the warehouse stock available in that period. Its cost is , and is the infimum of over nonanticipative feasible policies.
Each retailer and the supplier have a single-location problem. The value is the optimal long-run average cost of retailer facing its own demand with setup cost and holding and backlog cost , where is its demand over periods; is the analogous value for aggregate demand with cost , where and is aggregate demand over periods. The mirror cost of a retailer policy is the minimum over centers of the long-run average of , where is the retailer's inventory position including outstanding requests.
The FIFO policy (Definition 1 of the source) lets each retailer with plan at setup cost , take an optimal pair satisfying the canonical conditions and the best half window of , and use whichever has the smaller augmented cost (its own average cost plus its mirror cost); retailers with use base stock. Retailer orders form one first-in, first-out queue at the warehouse, served from available stock with partial fills, and the supplier follows an rule attaining on the aggregate position . The consolidation policy (Definition 2) keeps the FIFO queue but holds allocated stock until a dispatch threshold is reached, with retailer and supplier plans tuned to a parameter . The DFR policy (Definition D.1) uses the same FIFO mechanism, plans each retailer with at setup cost , and then keeps the canonical window, shortens it so that cycles last a fraction as long on average, or switches to base stock, with chosen to balance setup and mirror costs.
Let , , and . If for every retailer, , and , then from every valid initial state and at all finite lead times
With and , this is the guarantee under , , and .
Let . If retailer demands within a period are associated, for every retailer, and , then for all nonnegative setup costs, all finite lead times, and every valid initial state
Let and . If , , and for every retailer, and each retailer with has an absolutely continuous distribution with a decreasing failure rate conditional on positive demand, then with the policy is nonanticipative and feasible, and from every valid initial state and at all finite lead times
The result. Theorem 1 gives a constant factor for an implementable echelon stock policy relative to the best of all nonanticipative policies, including history-dependent and randomized ones. The factor does not depend on the supplier or retailer lead times or on the number of retailers, demand distributions are general (point masses and unbounded support are allowed), and demand may be correlated across retailers. Theorem 2 removes the restriction on setup-cost ratios at the price of a larger factor and the assumption that retailer demands are associated, and the source combines the two into a guarantee that depends only on cost parameters (its Corollary 1). Theorem D.1 lowers the factor to when retailer demand has a decreasing failure rate.
Formalizing it. Theorems 1, 2 and D.1 are proved in the source paper, and this mission's Lean proofs check all three for every admissible choice of the parameters the source leaves open. The formalization certifies the chain of arguments from single-location inventory theory to the network guarantees and provides reusable results for stochastic inventory theory, including renewal-measure bounds and renewal-reward identities for sums of i.i.d. nonnegative variables. Average-cost optimality of policies for general demand (Lemma 1 of the source) is also proved in Lean as a milestone, and a further milestone proves that choices satisfying Definitions 1, 2 and D.1 always exist, so the guarantees apply to policies that exist. Further milestones prove Corollary 1, which selects the FIFO or the consolidation policy by the setup-cost ratio, and Lemmas 3, 4, 8, D.1 and D.2 as stated in the source.
The benchmark ranges over all nonanticipative policies of an infinite-horizon average-cost problem whose optimal policy structure is unknown, so the comparison cannot go through an optimality equation for the network. The serial decomposition of Clark and Scarf does not apply to distribution systems, and relaxations that rebalance retailer inventories freely ignore the mismatch that retailer batching creates between warehouse stock and retailer orders. With a positive supplier lead time, purchases cannot clear pending requests at once, so one request may be filled in several portions across supplier receipts, each carrying a setup cost. All of this has to hold for general demand distributions, which rules out arguments that need discrete demand or densities.
Demand vectors live in Fin n → ℝ≥0 with a probability law , and the demands of the first periods have law . Costs are extended nonnegative reals: is the limsup of times the lower Lebesgue integral of the total cost of the first periods, and is an infimum over every auxiliary probability space and every measurable, nonanticipative policy that is feasible for every value of the auxiliary randomness and every demand path. Single-location values start from position (they do not depend on the initial position, as the source shows and the Lemma 1 milestone proves in Lean), and long-run averages of policies start at the order-up-to level. Both policies are deterministic state machines driven by past demands. The choices the source leaves open (optimal pairs satisfying the canonical conditions, minimizing half windows, the shortened windows and targets of the DFR policy, mirror centers, the supplier pair, the fixed retailer and fixed offsets used at initialization, and the enumeration of rationals in the offset rule) are explicit parameters constrained by predicates, and the theorems quantify over every admissible choice. Requests created in the same period are ordered by retailer index. Policies, and the test functions in the association condition, are required to be measurable.
The choice predicates are satisfiable for every network with at least one retailer meeting the standing assumptions (for the DFR policy, together with its demand assumption), as the existence milestone proves, so the targets are not vacuous, and the conclusions bound the cost of the constructed policies rather than of a relaxation.
A complete development needs renewal theory for sums of i.i.d. nonnegative variables (renewal-reward identities for expected time averages), average-cost optimality of policies with general demand, convexity and Jensen-type bounds for newsvendor costs, and covariance inequalities for associated random vectors. The single-location and renewal results are reusable beyond this mission. Formalizations of the source's intermediate results (Proposition 1, Propositions 2 and 3, and the lemmas of Appendix C) are welcome as additional milestones.
namespace OWMR
theorem general_fifo_guarantee {n : ℕ} (hn : 0 < n) (N : Network n) (hN : N.Standing)
(m γ : ℝ) (hm : 1 ≤ m) (hγ : 9 / 4 + 1 / (4 * m) ≤ γ)
(hH : ∀ i, m * N.h ≤ N.H i) (hp : N.h ≤ N.p) (hK : N.Kmax ≤ (γ - 1) * N.K0)
(x : InitState n) (hx : x.Valid) (c : FIFOChoice n) (hc : IsFIFOChoice N c) :
(fifoPolicy N x c).avgCost N x ≤ ENNReal.ofReal γ * OPT N x := by sorry
end OWMRLet , define , and let . Consider an OWMR network with retailers that satisfies the standing assumptions: demand vectors i.i.d. over periods with nonnegative components and , setup costs , and . Suppose
Then, from every valid initial state and at all finite supplier and retailer lead times, the deterministic FIFO policy of Definition 1 satisfies
Taking and gives when , , and for every . This is the main result of the source: a constant factor for an echelon stock policy relative to all nonanticipative policies, independent of the lead times and the number of retailers.
Formalization Note The conclusion holds for every admissible choice in Definition 1 (IsFIFOChoice N c). and take values in , and enters through ENNReal.ofReal.
No open leaves. Every sub-goal is proved or awaiting decomposition.