Compressing an operator to a closed subspace keeps the information visible within that subspace but can discard interactions with its orthogonal complement. The compression-rigidity question asks whether a particular equality detects that no such interactions were present. Its inputs are two commuting positive contractions and an ordinary strictly convex function of two real variables. The issue is the equality case, not the existence of a general operator inequality for every convex function.
The question was contributed by Boris Bilich to the CUHK-Shenzhen AI Math Problems collection and added on June 1, 2026. The original problem asks about operators on a Hilbert space without imposing finite dimension. The first formal target in this mission treated matrices with supplied joint spectral data. That finite-dimensional declaration has a verified proof on Prove2Me, but it does not settle the unrestricted Hilbert-space question. The September 2026 correction restores arbitrary complex Hilbert spaces as the main target and preserves the earlier result as a supporting artifact.
Let be a complete complex Hilbert space, and let be its algebra of bounded complex-linear operators. The multiplication means composition, with acting first, and denotes the adjoint. A positive contraction is self-adjoint, satisfies for every , and has operator norm at most one. Both zero and the identity are permitted.
Write . Let be positive contractions satisfying . Their joint continuous functional calculus assigns an operator to each continuous real function on . It is characterized as a continuous unital real star-algebra homomorphism from to that maps the two coordinate functions to and . The domain has the uniform norm and the codomain the operator norm. The existence and uniqueness of this calculus follow from the standard joint spectral theorem; the relevant source is Dereziński, Lemma 6.6, printed page 43.
An orthogonal projection is an operator satisfying and . The compressed operators and are still viewed as operators on the original space , not as operators on a separately chosen finite-dimensional range. The question includes the additional hypothesis that these compressed operators commute. The original commutation of and does not remove the need to state this hypothesis.
The main target is the entire compression implication from the source. Let be continuous and strictly convex: for distinct and , its value at is strictly less than . For as above, the question is whether
Both outer projections on the right are part of the original assertion. There is no hypothesis that . Commutation of with each coordinate operator is exactly the reducing-subspace conclusion asked for in the source.
The accompanying standard infrastructure target asserts that, for every commuting pair of positive contractions on ,
where is continuous, unital, real-linear, multiplicative and star-preserving. This is the unit-square, real-valued-function specialization of Lemma 6.6, not a claim that this known theorem is a new research conjecture. Its Lean proof is a separate supporting obligation. The earlier two-dimensional milestone and the proved finite-dimensional capstone remain available; neither replaces the new main target.
A positive resolution would show that exact preservation of one strictly convex functional-calculus value, under the specified commuting-compression hypothesis, forces both operators to preserve the projection's range and its orthogonal complement. A negative resolution would require an actual Hilbert space, operators and strictly convex function satisfying every hypothesis while at least one of the two reducing identities fails.
The formal development separates this research question from the standard spectral infrastructure needed to express it. The new main declaration is an open proof obligation. The joint-calculus existence-and-uniqueness declaration is also unproved in this contribution, although mathematically standard. Local compilation and server publication check the declarations' well-formedness; they are not proofs of either statement. Only the earlier finite-dimensional result is being reported here as already proved.
Arbitrary bounded commuting self-adjoint operators need not have a joint eigenbasis. Consequently a matrix formulation that records finitely many joint spectral atoms cannot serve as the general operator model. The compressed pair may also have different spectral data from the original pair. The equality involves these two different functional calculi, with a projection on either side of each value.
Strict convexity in this question is ordinary scalar strict convexity on the square. Operator convexity, finite rank of the projection, compactness of the coordinate operators, and a multivariable operator Jensen inequality are not additional assumptions. Introducing any of them would change the requested question. The general formulation must also retain boundary cases rather than exclude them to simplify an argument.
The Lean model uses actual bounded complex-linear maps on an arbitrary complete inner-product space. It imposes no finite-dimensionality, separability, common-eigenbasis or nonzero-space assumption. It includes , and the zero Hilbert space. The scalar field convention is complex; a real-Hilbert-space transfer is not separately formalized here.
The function is stored on the ambient real plane, but continuity, strict convexity and evaluation use only its restriction to . Values outside are irrelevant, and continuity outside the square is not required. Thus storing an ambient function does not exclude any continuous function originally defined only on the square.
Joint evaluation is a total definition. If a representing continuous unital real star-algebra homomorphism exists, it chooses one for the operator pair and then evaluates the supplied function. Otherwise it returns zero. The separate existence-and-uniqueness target establishes that this fallback is inapplicable to commuting positive contractions and that the choice is immaterial. No field in the model assumes the compression-rigidity conclusion. The supporting standard theorem must also apply to the compressed pair using the original projection and positivity hypotheses, without adding representation existence as a new restriction on the main question.
The replacement definition and both statements were built at Lean 4.30.0 with supported Mathlib revision c5ea00351c28e24afc9f0f84379aa41082b1188f, and their final versions received independent blind readbacks. Published older declarations and their proof identities are preserved. They should be cited with their finite-dimensional scope, not described as a solution of the arbitrary-Hilbert-space target.
namespace RybinAI2026.P02Hilbert
/-- Strict Jensen equality for the joint continuous functional calculus on an arbitrary
complex Hilbert space forces the projection to reduce both coordinate operators. -/
theorem hilbert_compression_rigidity
(H : Type*) [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H] [CompleteSpace H]
(f : (Fin 2 → ℝ) → ℝ) (hf : ContinuousOn f unitSquare)
(hstrict : StrictConvexOn ℝ unitSquare f)
(X Y : H →L[ℂ] H) (hX : PositiveContraction X) (hY : PositiveContraction Y)
(hXY : X * Y = Y * X)
(P : H →L[ℂ] H) (hPstar : star P = P) (hPidempotent : P * P = P)
(hCompressedCommute : (P * X * P) * (P * Y * P) = (P * Y * P) * (P * X * P))
(hEquality : P * jointCFC X Y (restrictFunction f hf) * P =
P * jointCFC (P * X * P) (P * Y * P) (restrictFunction f hf) * P) :
P * X = X * P ∧ P * Y = Y * P := by
sorry
end RybinAI2026.P02HilbertLet be any complete complex Hilbert space and let be continuous and strictly convex. Let be commuting positive contractions on , and let be an orthogonal projection for which and commute. With the joint continuous functional calculus, the proposed assertion is
This is the arbitrary-complex-Hilbert-space compression question, not just its finite-dimensional matrix instance. It includes the zero space and the projections zero and identity; no assumption that is made. All compressed operators act on the original space , and both outer projections on the right are retained.
Formalization Note. The function is stored on the ambient real plane but only its restriction to the square is used. Joint evaluation is defined by classical choice from continuous unital real star-algebra homomorphisms with the specified coordinate images, or zero when no representation exists. The standard existence-and-uniqueness theorem for commuting positive contractions justifies this representation. Its separate formal statement is supplied as a supporting obligation; neither that lemma nor the open rigidity claim is asserted to have a completed Lean proof here.
No open leaves. Every sub-goal is proved or awaiting decomposition.