A metric space is plastic if every nonexpansive bijection of it onto itself is an isometry. Every totally bounded metric space is plastic (Freudenthal–Hurewicz 1936; the term is from Naimpally–Piotrowski–Wingler 2006), and Cascales, Kadets, Orihuela and Wingler (2016) asked whether the closed unit ball of every real Banach space is plastic. The answer is known to be yes for strictly convex spaces (CKOW 2016), for ℓ₁ and ℓ₁-sums of strictly convex spaces (Kadets–Zavarzina 2016, 2018), for finite ℓ∞-sums of strictly convex spaces (Haller–Leo–Zavarzina 2022 for two summands; Kurik 2025 under an extra hypothesis), and for c and for c₀ under continuity of the inverse (Leo 2022), among others; it is open for L¹[0,1] and C[0,1].
A recurring step in these proofs is to show that the map preserves the unit sphere and then that a sphere-preserving map is linear. The published versions of the second step assume homogeneity on rays, or oddness, in addition to sphere preservation (CKOW 2016, Lemma 2.5; Zavarzina 2018, Corollary 2.6; Kadets–Zavarzina 2018, Lemma 2.9). This mission formalizes a version that needs only sphere preservation, together with a strengthening in which surjectivity onto the ball is replaced by coverage of the target sphere. The results come from an unpublished research project on the plasticity problem.
and are real Banach spaces, and .
A map is nonexpansive if for all .
In Lean a map of balls is a function F : X → Y on the whole space, constrained on the ball by Set.MapsTo, Set.SurjOn and LipschitzOnWith 1; its values outside play no role.
The goal and its milestones, from the most special tool to the strongest statement:
In U10 and U16, and are nonzero.
The result. U10 reduces the plasticity problem in every real Banach space to sphere preservation, and U16 to coverage of the target sphere by the image of the sphere; the reductions hold between two different spaces, which matters because the plasticity problem is equivalent to its two-space form (Kurik 2025, Theorem 3.1). They also show that sphere preservation, preservation of every norm, and being an isometry are equivalent for nonexpansive surjections of unit balls.
Formalizing it. The proofs exist only in the project's own notes and have been checked by AI referees and partly by the author; a machine-checked proof is the independent confirmation sought. Mathlib has no theory of nonexpansive or averaged maps, so the development will contribute uniform asymptotic regularity of averaged nonexpansive maps (Borzdyński–Wiśnicki; Goebel–Kirk 1990, Theorem 9.4), U16 needs the Bishop–Phelps theorem, which Mathlib also lacks, and the quantitative form of A01 needs the sharp rate of Cominetti, Soto and Vaisman for averaged maps (arXiv:1206.4195, Theorem 1); it is not needed for U10 or U16.
No injectivity, oddness, homogeneity, smoothness or continuity of an inverse is assumed, so none of the standard routes to linearity applies: Mazur–Ulam needs an isometry, and the published sphere-preservation lemmas need homogeneity on rays. In U16 the map need not even be onto the ball.
Real scalars; arbitrary (not necessarily separable) Banach spaces, with CompleteSpace and, in U10 and U16, Nontrivial.
The conclusion of U10 and U16 is a LinearIsometryEquiv agreeing with F on the closed unit ball, so it includes surjectivity of the linear map.
A01 concludes Set.EqOn H id on the closed unit ball.
Statements are not to be weakened by adding injectivity, continuity of an inverse, or finite dimension.
Published inputs (Goebel–Kirk, Bishop–Phelps, Banach's fixed-point theorem from Mathlib) may be added as separate cards and imported by proof sketches.
namespace Plasticity
theorem U16 {X Y : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup X] [NormedSpace ℝ X] [CompleteSpace X] [Nontrivial X]
[NormedAddCommGroup Y] [NormedSpace ℝ Y] [CompleteSpace Y] [Nontrivial Y]
(F : X → Y)
(hmaps : Set.MapsTo F (Metric.closedBall (0 : X) 1) (Metric.closedBall (0 : Y) 1))
(hlip : LipschitzOnWith 1 F (Metric.closedBall (0 : X) 1))
(hsphere : Set.MapsTo F (Metric.sphere (0 : X) 1) (Metric.sphere (0 : Y) 1))
(hcover : Metric.sphere (0 : Y) 1 ⊆ F '' Metric.closedBall (0 : X) 1) :
∃ T : X ≃ₗᵢ[ℝ] Y, Set.EqOn F T (Metric.closedBall (0 : X) 1) := by sorry
end PlasticityLet and be nonzero real Banach spaces and let be a nonexpansive map of their closed unit balls. If and every unit vector of is the image of some point of , then is the restriction to of a surjective real-linear isometry . Coverage of interior targets, injectivity and inverse regularity are not assumed.
No open leaves. Every sub-goal is proved or awaiting decomposition.