Appendix, Theorem 2: the no-return wholesale price
ProvedPerishableReturns.Suboptimal.appendix_theorem_2_no_returnsp2o-batch-pfp2bp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1supply-chain-coordinationwholesale-price
Suppose , and . With no returns (), equations (9)–(10) reduce to an equality that holds if and only if the wholesale price is
The right side is at most , so under the reduced equation
fails. The statement asserts both the equivalence and this failure, as the proof of Theorem 2 does.
Formalization Note When , the credit does not affect the retailer's profit or this equation. The denominator is positive because and . The paper does not state separately, but calls it a goodwill cost; this sign is necessary for the ensuing contradiction.
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_PerishableReturns_Suboptimal_Model
Formal statement
namespace PerishableReturns.Suboptimal
/-- Appendix, proof of Theorem 2, p. 175: at `R = 0`, (9)–(10) is equivalent to
`c1 = c − g1(c − c3)/(p + g2 − c3)`, and this contradicts `c1 > c`. -/
theorem appendix_theorem_2_no_returns (K : Costs) (c1 : ℝ)
(hc : K.c < c1) (hp : c1 < K.p) :
((0 = (c1 - K.p - K.g) +
(K.p + K.g2 - K.c) * (K.p + K.g - K.c3) / (K.p + K.g2 - K.c3)) ↔
c1 = K.c - K.g1 * (K.c - K.c3) / (K.p + K.g2 - K.c3)) ∧
0 ≠ (c1 - K.p - K.g) +
(K.p + K.g2 - K.c) * (K.p + K.g - K.c3) / (K.p + K.g2 - K.c3) := by sorry
end PerishableReturns.Suboptimal
Source
Pasternack, Optimal Pricing and Return Policies for Perishable Commodities, Marketing Science 4(2) (1985), Appendix, proof of Theorem 2, p. 175
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.