The Lenz coincidence is not exact:
ProvedProtonElectronMassRatio.lenz_coincidence_not_exactLet be reals whose ratio is the CODATA 2022 value, . Then Lenz's expression is not that ratio; it is separated from it by more than standard uncertainties,
its relative deviation satisfies
and nevertheless lies strictly inside the 1951 experimental error bar, . Together these say exactly that Lenz's 1951 observation is a numerical coincidence: consistent with the data he had, refuted by the data available now.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ProtonElectronMassRatio_constants
namespace ProtonElectronMassRatio
theorem lenz_coincidence_not_exact (mproton melectron : ℝ)
(h : mproton / melectron = codataValue) :
mproton / melectron ≠ lenzExpression ∧
codataUncertainty * 10 ^ 6 < |mproton / melectron - lenzExpression| ∧
0.0000188 < (mproton / melectron - lenzExpression) / (mproton / melectron) ∧
(mproton / melectron - lenzExpression) / (mproton / melectron) < 0.0000189 ∧
|lenzExpression - lenz1951Measurement| < lenz1951Uncertainty := by sorry
end ProtonElectronMassRatioRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · self-authored by the drafting agent (non-blind; no independent auditor was used)
⚠️ NON-BLIND READ-BACK — NOT INDEPENDENT TESTIMONY. This read-back was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statement above, at the explicit instruction of the proposal owner. It is therefore not blind auditor testimony: its author knew the intended meaning, the source text, and the mission's purpose, so it cannot detect the failure mode read-backs exist to catch (the author reading intended meaning into code that does not say it). No reviewer should treat it as independent confirmation; an independent, blind read-back should be obtained before this item is relied upon.
The statement takes two real parameters, called and , subject to one hypothesis: their quotient equals the constant . (The hypothesis is satisfiable, for instance by and , so the claim is not vacuous; no positivity, nonzeroness or physical interpretation of or is assumed, and division is the total real quotient.) Writing for the constant , for , for and for , the conclusion is a conjunction of five separate claims, all of which are asserted simultaneously:
- ;
- , i.e. the difference exceeds in absolute value (sign unspecified by this clause);
- ;
- ;
- , i.e. .
Clauses 3 and 4 together force , so is strictly the smaller number; the relative deviation is normalized by , not by . Clause 5 does not mention or at all: it is a closed statement about and two constants. All inequalities are strict.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.