Proposition 4 — if is strictly feasible (2.9), (2.6) and (2.8) have the same optimal value
ProvedPrimalDualLDR.FixedRecourse.proposition_4Assume the standing assumptions of §2, and suppose that is strictly feasible: there are and decision rules , with
where is the all-ones vector. Then the optimal values of problem (2.6) and of the linear program (2.8),
coincide (as elements of ).
Without strict feasibility the two values only bracket each other through Proposition 3; strict feasibility removes the gap, and with the §2.4 reformulation this identifies the dual approximation with a linear program.
Formalization Note Repaired statement: the formal statement adds the hypothesis (some row of , 1-based, is nonzero), which the paper does not state. Without it the printed proposition is false: for , , , , , , , , problem is strictly feasible (, ), so (2.8) has no sign constraint on and value , while (2.6) forces and has value . Under the standing assumptions holds automatically when . Optimal values are infima in .
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_PrimalDualLDR_FixedRecourse_Basic import Definitions.Def_PrimalDualLDR_FixedRecourse_Setting import Definitions.Def_PrimalDualLDR_FixedRecourse_Problems open MeasureTheory Matrix
namespace PrimalDualLDR.FixedRecourse
/-- Proposition 4 (p. 9): under the standing assumptions of §2, if `SP` is strictly feasible (2.9),
then the optimal values of (2.6) and (2.8) coincide.
Repair (trap 30): the hypothesis `hW` says `Ŵ ≠ 0` (some row `i ≥ 2` of `W` is nonzero; rows
`0`, `1` are `±e_1ᵀ`). The page omits it, and the printed statement is false without it: for
`k = 1`, `l = 2`, `W = (1, −1)ᵀ`, `h = (1, −1)`, `P = δ_1`, the matrix `W − h e_1ᵀ` is `0`, so
`𝒦 = ℝ` while `𝒦_P = [0, ∞)`; with `n = m = 1`, `A = B = 1`, `C = −1` (strictly feasible with
`x̄ = 0`, `s̄(ξ) = ξ`) the program (2.8) loses `S ≥ 0` and has value `−∞`, while (2.6) and `SP^l`
have value `−1`. Under the standing assumptions `Ŵ ≠ 0` is automatic when `k ≥ 2`. -/
theorem proposition_4 (σ : Setting) (hσ : σ.Standing)
(hW : ∃ i : Fin σ.l, 2 ≤ i.val ∧ σ.W i ≠ 0) (hsf : σ.StrictlyFeasible) :
σ.valLP26 = σ.valLP28 := by sorry
end PrimalDualLDR.FixedRecourse
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.