Manin's unimodular paths span: every value of a modular symbol is an integral combination of its values on unimodular paths
ProvedMTT.Cohomology.manin_generation_spanManin's unimodular-path theorem, in the form that is actually used when one needs to produce elements rather than merely detect them.
Let and let be the group of degree-zero divisors on the cusps, with denoting . A unimodular path is a divisor of the form with , i.e. a path joining to ; equivalently, a path between two cusps and with . Manin's continued-fraction trick shows that these generate as an abelian group: writing as the last convergent of its continued fraction expansion, the successive convergents and satisfy , so the path from to telescopes into finitely many unimodular pieces.
The statement here is the consequence of that for a modular symbol. If
then applying to such a decomposition expresses every value as a -linear combination of the values of on unimodular paths:
Note that the subgroup on the right is generated by the values of the same , so no auxiliary object appears in the statement, and no equivariance is used in it — the equivariance of enters only in the proof, and only through .
Relation to the vanishing form. This statement strictly implies MTT.Cohomology.manin_generation (if all the generators vanish, the subgroup is trivial and ), but it is genuinely stronger, and the difference matters. The vanishing form says only that a class is determined by its unimodular values; it gives an injection into a finite-dimensional coordinate space but says nothing about which coefficients actually occur. The spanning form says the values are built from the unimodular values, which is what lets one bound the subgroup of generated by all coefficients of all values of a single class — a finiteness statement no injectivity result can supply, and the input to flat base change.
import Definitions.Def_MTT_Cohomology import Mathlib.RingTheory.Flat.Basic set_option autoImplicit false noncomputable section open scoped BigOperators TensorProduct open MTT.Cohomology
theorem MTT.Cohomology.manin_generation_span
{N n : ℕ} {R : Type*} [CommRing R] (φ : Hc N n R) (x y : Cusp) :
φ.val (x, y) ∈ AddSubgroup.closure
(Set.range fun g : Matrix.SpecialLinearGroup (Fin 2) ℤ =>
φ.val (cuspAct g ((0 : ℚ) : Cusp), cuspAct g OnePoint.infty)) := by sorry