Observation 3, p. 8774 — source preference and source insensitivity are transitive; the new insensitivity region is the intersection
ProvedSourceTheory.EqualSources.observation_3ambiguitydecision-theoryp2o-batch-pfp2ap2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1source-of-uncertaintytransitivity
Let , and satisfy structural Assumption 1 on the events , and let , and be sources.
- Source preference is transitive. If is preferred to and is preferred to (Definition 2), then is preferred to .
- Source insensitivity is transitive. Let . If is more insensitive than with region and is more insensitive than with region , then for all events with
is more insensitive than with region .
The region in part 2 is any region inside the intersection of and in the event order. The observation lets a chain of comparisons between sources be collapsed into one comparison, which the proof of Theorem 4 uses to compare each source with itself.
Formalization Note. Event preference is -order, so "" is . The paper's middle source is called ; here it is , to avoid a clash with the boundary event .
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_SourceTheory_Uniform_Model open Set
Formal statement
namespace SourceTheory.EqualSources
/-- Observation 3 (p. 8774): source preference and source insensitivity are transitive; for
insensitivity the new region is the intersection of the other two (any `[B, D]` with `B ≽ B₁, B₂` and
`D ≼ D₁, D₂`). The middle source is written `𝒮`. -/
theorem observation_3 {S Γ : Type*} (𝓔 : Set (Set S)) (pref : (S → Γ) → (S → Γ) → Prop)
(U : Γ → ℝ) (W : Set S → ℝ) (h1 : SourceTheory.Uniform.Assumption1 𝓔 pref U W)
(𝒜 𝒮 𝒞 : Set (Set S)) (h𝒜 : SourceTheory.Uniform.IsSource 𝓔 W 𝒜) (h𝒮 : SourceTheory.Uniform.IsSource 𝓔 W 𝒮)
(h𝒞 : SourceTheory.Uniform.IsSource 𝓔 W 𝒞) :
(SourceTheory.Uniform.IsPreferredTo W 𝒮 𝒜 → SourceTheory.Uniform.IsPreferredTo W 𝒞 𝒮 → SourceTheory.Uniform.IsPreferredTo W 𝒞 𝒜) ∧
(∀ B₁ ∈ 𝓔, ∀ D₁ ∈ 𝓔, ∀ B₂ ∈ 𝓔, ∀ D₂ ∈ 𝓔,
SourceTheory.Uniform.IsMoreInsensitive W 𝒜 𝒮 B₁ D₁ → SourceTheory.Uniform.IsMoreInsensitive W 𝒮 𝒞 B₂ D₂ →
∀ B ∈ 𝓔, ∀ D ∈ 𝓔, W B₁ ≤ W B → W B₂ ≤ W B → W D ≤ W D₁ → W D ≤ W D₂ →
SourceTheory.Uniform.IsMoreInsensitive W 𝒜 𝒞 B D) := by sorry
end SourceTheory.EqualSources
Source
Baillon et al. (2025), Management Science 71(10), Observation 3, p. 8774 (proof p. 8779)
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.