Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

No signalling in the Eppley–Hannah EPR set-up: photon 2 is in the same state ρ^\hat\rhoρ^​ before and after the measurement of photon 1

Proved
AKR2008.photon2_same_reduced_state

by LG · Sep 23, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

mathematical-physicsno-signallingpartial-tracequantum-information

Let H\mathcal HH be a complex inner-product space (the detector), and let Φ0,Φ↑,Φ↓∈H\Phi_0,\Phi_\uparrow,\Phi_\downarrow\in\mathcal HΦ0​,Φ↑​,Φ↓​∈H be unit vectors: Φ0\Phi_0Φ0​ is the initial (switched-off) detector state and Φ↑\Phi_\uparrowΦ↑​, Φ↓\Phi_\downarrowΦ↓​ are the detector states after recording horizontal, resp. vertical, polarization of photon 1. Consider the joint states of photon 1, photon 2 and the detector before and after the measurement,

∣Ψ0⟩=12(∣↑⟩1∣↓⟩2−∣↓⟩1∣↑⟩2)∣Φ0⟩,∣Ψ⟩=12(∣↑⟩1∣↓⟩2∣Φ↑⟩−∣↓⟩1∣↑⟩2∣Φ↓⟩).|\Psi_0\rangle = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}\bigl(|\uparrow\rangle_1|\downarrow\rangle_2 - |\downarrow\rangle_1|\uparrow\rangle_2\bigr)|\Phi_0\rangle,\qquad |\Psi\rangle = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt2}\bigl(|\uparrow\rangle_1|\downarrow\rangle_2|\Phi_\uparrow\rangle - |\downarrow\rangle_1|\uparrow\rangle_2|\Phi_\downarrow\rangle\bigr).∣Ψ0​⟩=2​1​(∣↑⟩1​∣↓⟩2​−∣↓⟩1​∣↑⟩2​)∣Φ0​⟩,∣Ψ⟩=2​1​(∣↑⟩1​∣↓⟩2​∣Φ↑​⟩−∣↓⟩1​∣↑⟩2​∣Φ↓​⟩).

Then both lead to the same reduced density operator of photon 2:

ρ2(Ψ0)=ρ^andρ2(Ψ)=ρ^,ρ^=12(∣↑⟩2⟨↑∣2+∣↓⟩2⟨↓∣2).\rho_2(\Psi_0) = \hat\rho \quad\text{and}\quad \rho_2(\Psi) = \hat\rho, \qquad \hat\rho = \tfrac12\bigl(|\uparrow\rangle_2\langle\uparrow|_2 + |\downarrow\rangle_2\langle\downarrow|_2\bigr).ρ2​(Ψ0​)=ρ^​andρ2​(Ψ)=ρ^​,ρ^​=21​(∣↑⟩2​⟨↑∣2​+∣↓⟩2​⟨↓∣2​).

This is the statement on which the paper bases its rebuttal of the superluminal-signalling branch of the Eppley–Hannah argument: a probe (such as a classical gravitational wave) interacting with photon 2 alone sees the same mixed state whether or not photon 1 has been measured.

Formalization Note The detector states are only required to be unit vectors; see the mission description for the representation of the tensor product and the partial trace.

Preamble
import Definitions.Def_AKR2008_Defs
Formal statement
namespace AKR2008

theorem photon2_same_reduced_state
    {H : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup H] [InnerProductSpace ℂ H]
    (Φ₀ Φup Φdown : H) (h₀ : ‖Φ₀‖ = 1) (hup : ‖Φup‖ = 1) (hdown : ‖Φdown‖ = 1) :
    reducedPhoton2 (psiBefore Φ₀) = rhoHat ∧ reducedPhoton2 (psiAfter Φup Φdown) = rhoHat := by
  sorry

end AKR2008
Source
M. Albers, C. Kiefer, M. Reginatto, Measurement analysis and quantum gravity, Phys. Rev. D 78, 064051 (2008), https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.78.064051, p. 064051-2, Sec. II, Eqs. (1)–(3) and the sentence "This leads for both (1) and (2) to the same density operator for photon 2"
Read-back

What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic) — non-blind, same agent as drafter

Non-blind read-back — not independent testimony. This read-back was written by the same agent (Aristotle, by Harmonic) that drafted the Lean statements, with full knowledge of the source paper and of the intended meaning. It is not a blind audit and must not be mistaken for independent testimony; an independent blind read-back is still recommended before the proposal is submitted.

Statement. Let HHH be any complex inner-product space (implicit). Let Φ0,Φ↑,Φ↓∈H\Phi_0,\Phi_\uparrow,\Phi_\downarrow\in HΦ0​,Φ↑​,Φ↓​∈H with ∥Φ0∥=∥Φ↑∥=∥Φ↓∥=1\|\Phi_0\| = \|\Phi_\uparrow\| = \|\Phi_\downarrow\| = 1∥Φ0​∥=∥Φ↑​∥=∥Φ↓​∥=1. Then both of the following hold:

  1. reducedPhoton2(psiBefore(Φ0))=rhoHat\mathrm{reducedPhoton2}(\mathrm{psiBefore}(\Phi_0)) = \mathrm{rhoHat}reducedPhoton2(psiBefore(Φ0​))=rhoHat;
  2. reducedPhoton2(psiAfter(Φ↑,Φ↓))=rhoHat\mathrm{reducedPhoton2}(\mathrm{psiAfter}(\Phi_\uparrow,\Phi_\downarrow)) = \mathrm{rhoHat}reducedPhoton2(psiAfter(Φ↑​,Φ↓​))=rhoHat.

Unfolding the definitions: psiBefore(Φ0)\mathrm{psiBefore}(\Phi_0)psiBefore(Φ0​) has components Ψ01=12Φ0\Psi_{01}=\tfrac1{\sqrt2}\Phi_0Ψ01​=2​1​Φ0​, Ψ10=−12Φ0\Psi_{10}=-\tfrac1{\sqrt2}\Phi_0Ψ10​=−2​1​Φ0​, Ψ00=Ψ11=0\Psi_{00}=\Psi_{11}=0Ψ00​=Ψ11​=0; psiAfter(Φ↑,Φ↓)\mathrm{psiAfter}(\Phi_\uparrow,\Phi_\downarrow)psiAfter(Φ↑​,Φ↓​) has Ψ01=12Φ↑\Psi_{01}=\tfrac1{\sqrt2}\Phi_\uparrowΨ01​=2​1​Φ↑​, Ψ10=−12Φ↓\Psi_{10}=-\tfrac1{\sqrt2}\Phi_\downarrowΨ10​=−2​1​Φ↓​, others 000; reducedPhoton2(Ψ)jj′=∑i=01⟨Ψij′,Ψij⟩H\mathrm{reducedPhoton2}(\Psi)_{jj'} = \sum_{i=0}^1\langle\Psi_{ij'},\Psi_{ij}\rangle_HreducedPhoton2(Ψ)jj′​=∑i=01​⟨Ψij′​,Ψij​⟩H​ (conjugate-linear in the first slot); rhoHat=12I2\mathrm{rhoHat} = \tfrac12 I_2rhoHat=21​I2​.

The conclusion is a conjunction of two 2×22\times22×2 complex matrix equalities (it does not separately state that the two reduced matrices equal each other, though this follows). No orthogonality relation between Φ0,Φ↑,Φ↓\Phi_0,\Phi_\uparrow,\Phi_\downarrowΦ0​,Φ↑​,Φ↓​ is assumed. The hypotheses are satisfiable exactly when H≠{0}H\neq\{0\}H={0}.

Human review
  • Endorsed by Shuze Chen · Sep 24, 2026

    Confirmed by the moderator at approval.

  • Endorsed by LG · Sep 24, 2026

    Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me