p. 4 — at , a readjusted witness exceeds 1
ProvedBMV2017.witnessRot_gt_oneLet with . There exist real such that, with each spin's operators readjusted by the local phase rotation , ,
Formalization Note With the unrotated operators of p. 3 the witness on this state is about , not the stated ; the maximum over local phase rotations is . This corrected form is what is formalized; the value is not.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_PeresTerno_kraus_basics import Definitions.Def_BMV2017_defs open Matrix open scoped Kronecker ComplexOrder
namespace BMV2017
theorem witnessRot_gt_one :
∃ θ₁ θ₂ : ℝ, 1 < witnessRot θ₁ θ₂ (pureDM (psiEnd (-1 / 5) (7 / 10))) := by sorry
end BMV2017Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5
Read-back of BMV2017.witnessRot_gt_one.
What it asserts. There is no hypothesis and nothing is universally quantified. The statement is purely existential. There exist real numbers (any reals, with no range restriction and no reduction mod ) such that the strict inequality
holds. Here is one specific two-qubit vector with fixed numerical parameters, and is the "rotated witness" defined below. The theorem only claims that at least one pair exists. It does not name the pair, does not say how many there are, and claims no bound beyond the strict lower bound .
The setting. A qubit index set is . Two-qubit vectors are functions , so they are -component vectors indexed by pairs , where the first entry belongs to "mass 1" and the second to "mass 2". Two-qubit matrices are complex matrices indexed by such pairs.
The vector. with and . These are real numbers (computed in , so there is no integer-division truncation) and are cast into . In general with . So, concretely,
that is, . Its squared Euclidean norm is , but the statement does not use or assert this anywhere.
The density matrix. is the matrix . For any matrix this gives , the expectation value with the conjugate-linear slot first.
The operators. The Pauli matrices are
The phase rotation is , and the rotated operators are , where is the conjugate transpose. Multiplying these out gives
The tensor product is the Kronecker product with the first factor acting on mass 1: .
The rotated witness. For a matrix ,
where is the complex modulus. The value is therefore a non-negative real number. The real part is not taken; the modulus is taken of the full complex difference. rotates the operators on mass 1 and rotates the operators on mass 2. Because , enters only through the second term . With , the theorem says that for some real ,
Edge cases and strength. The statement has no free variables and no hypotheses, so it cannot hold vacuously. It is a single concrete existential claim about the one vector above. The inequality is strict (, not ). Because the angles enter only through , the claim does not change if they are shifted by multiples of , and (the unrotated witness) is one of the allowed choices but is not singled out. No separability notion, density-matrix predicate, partial trace or purity appears in this statement, even though the imported file defines them.