The witness vector is not holographic.
ProvedEmergentGeometry.no_bulk_geometry_realises_Swaether-catalognovelty
The witness vector is not holographic. No bulk graph with five
pairwise disjoint boundary regions can have min-cut entropies given by Sw.
Since Sw satisfies subadditivity, SSA, weak monotonicity and monogamy, this
obstruction is invisible to those four families; it is detected precisely by the
cyclic inequality.
theorem EmergentGeometry.no_bulk_geometry_realises_Sw(M : HoloModel V) (A₀ A₁ A₂ A₃ A₄ : Region V)
(hd : ∀ v, AtMostOneTrue (A₀ v) (A₁ v) (A₂ v) (A₃ v) (A₄ v))
(hreal : ∀ b₀ b₁ b₂ b₃ b₄ : Bool,
entropy M (unionSel b₀ b₁ b₂ b₃ b₄ A₀ A₁ A₂ A₃ A₄) = (Sw (bmask b₀ b₁ b₂ b₃ b₄) : ℝ)) :
False := by sorry
Formalization Note Transplanted verbatim from the Aether Catalog source Novelty/CyclicIndependence.lean; the statement is byte-identical to the source declaration, elaborated with autoImplicit disabled in the platform environment.
Preamble
-- Thm stub generated from Novelty/CyclicIndependence.lean
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_CyclicIndependence
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_EmergentGeometryEntropyCone
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_HolographicCyclicInequality
/-!
# Independence of the five-party cyclic inequality, and a non-geometric entropy vector
`Novelty.HolographicCyclicInequality` proves that every min-cut ("holographic")
entropy assignment obeys the five-party cyclic inequality
`∑_j S(A_j A_{j+1}) + S(A₀A₁A₂A₃A₄) ≤ ∑_j S(A_j A_{j+1} A_{j+2})`.
This file establishes that this inequality is *not* a formal consequence of the
standard entropy inequalities available before it, namely
* **subadditivity** `S(XY) ≤ S(X) + S(Y)`,
* **strong subadditivity** `S(XYZ) + S(Y) ≤ S(XY) + S(YZ)`,
* **weak monotonicity** `S(X) + S(Z) ≤ S(XY) + S(YZ)`, and
* **monogamy of mutual information (MMI)**
`S(XY) + S(YZ) + S(XZ) ≥ S(XYZ) + S(X) + S(Y) + S(Z)`,
by exhibiting an explicit integer-valued five-party entropy vector `Sw` that
satisfies all four families on all pairwise disjoint arguments, yet violates the
cyclic inequality by exactly `1`.
Subsets of the five parties are encoded as bitmasks `0 ≤ m < 32`; unions become
`|||` and disjointness becomes `&&& = 0`. All four validity families are
verified by kernel evaluation over the full `32³ = 32768` case space of triples
of masks — this is a genuine exhaustive computation, not a definitional
unfolding.
The consequence for emergent geometry: **no** bulk graph whatsoever can produce
this entropy vector (`no_bulk_geometry_realises_Sw`). So the geometric states
form a strictly smaller cone than the quantum-mechanically consistent ones, and
"reconstruct the geometry from the entanglement" has a genuine obstruction that
is invisible to subadditivity, SSA, weak monotonicity and monogamy alone.
-/
noncomputable section
open EmergentGeometry
open Finset
/-! ## The witness vector -/
/-! ## The four validity families
Each is checked exhaustively over all masks below `32`. -/
/-! ## Packaging the independence statement -/
/-! ## No bulk geometry realises the witness -/
variable {V : Type*} [Fintype V] [DecidableEq V]Formal statement
theorem EmergentGeometry.no_bulk_geometry_realises_Sw(M : HoloModel V) (A₀ A₁ A₂ A₃ A₄ : Region V)
(hd : ∀ v, AtMostOneTrue (A₀ v) (A₁ v) (A₂ v) (A₃ v) (A₄ v))
(hreal : ∀ b₀ b₁ b₂ b₃ b₄ : Bool,
entropy M (unionSel b₀ b₁ b₂ b₃ b₄ A₀ A₁ A₂ A₃ A₄) = (Sw (bmask b₀ b₁ b₂ b₃ b₄) : ℝ)) :
False := by sorrySource