Fig. 2, p. 3 — one use of S = R_{2,2} with two-way classical communication implements a noiseless qubit channel
ProvedRetroCorr.Separation.fig2_noiseless_qubitLet be the standard retrocorrectable channel with qubit control and qubit data, with its Haar-distributed classical flag . There is a two-way assisted protocol that uses exactly once, with free classical communication in both directions and no prior entanglement, and transmits one qubit without error:
In the paper's protocol, Alice feeds the control input half of an ebit and the data input the message qubit; Bob announces ; Alice measures the other half of the ebit in and, by the echo effect, obtains the channel's hidden outcome , which she announces; Bob undoes . The statement asserts that such a protocol exists in the operational model used to define , and that its output equals its input on every state.
Formalization Note TwoWayCode (flagLaw 2 2) (retroBranch 2 2) 1 1 is a code with exactly one channel use for qubit (QAlgorithms.Qubits 1), in the adaptive model of RetroCorr.Separation.TwoWay; P.output ρ is Bob's final state. The flag is announced to both parties after the use, which is Bob telling Alice over the back channel.
Differences from the source:
- reading: "Protocol … to implement a noiseless qubit channel" (Fig. 2's specific protocol) → there exists a two-way code with one use of S whose output equals its input; reason: the caption's claim is that the protocol implements the identity channel, and the existence of such a code is that claim in the capacity model
- encoding: "noiseless qubit channel" → output = input for every one-qubit density matrix; reason: a noiseless channel is the identity on every state
- encoding: Bob tells Alice B; Alice tells Bob j → the flag and every instrument outcome are public; reason: free two-way classical communication
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_RetroCorr_Separation_Channel import Definitions.Def_RetroCorr_Separation_TwoWay
namespace RetroCorr.Separation
theorem fig2_noiseless_qubit :
∃ P : TwoWayCode (flagLaw 2 2) (retroBranch 2 2) 1 1,
∀ ρ : Matrix (QAlgorithms.Qubits 1) (QAlgorithms.Qubits 1) ℂ,
QAlgorithms.IsDensityMatrix ρ → P.output ρ = ρ := by sorry
end RetroCorr.Separation
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.