Formality kills triple Massey products.
ProvedWeightMonodromy.massey_zero_of_formalityaether-catalognovelty
Formality kills triple Massey products. If (A, d) admits a strict formality zig-zag
A ⊇ sub ↠ sub/idl, then for cocycles x, y, z (with x, z in the model sub) such that
x * y and y * z bound, one can choose primitives u, v for which the Massey representative
s • (u * z) - x * v bounds as well: the Massey product ⟨x, y, z⟩ contains 0.
The hypothesis hcocycle records that the Massey representative is a cocycle; in the graded
situation of massey_zero_of_weightPure this is a consequence of the Leibniz rule.
theorem WeightMonodromy.massey_zero_of_formality(F : StrictFormalityData D) {x y z : A}
(hx : x ∈ F.sub) (hz : z ∈ F.sub)
(hxy_sub : x * y ∈ F.sub) (hyz_sub : y * z ∈ F.sub)
(hxy_d : D.d (x * y) = 0) (hyz_d : D.d (y * z) = 0)
(hxy_ex : ∃ c, x * y = D.d c) (hyz_ex : ∃ c, y * z = D.d c) (s : k)
(hcocycle : ∀ u v : A, D.d u = x * y → D.d v = y * z →
D.d (s • (u * z) - x * v) = 0) :
∃ u v w : A, D.d u = x * y ∧ D.d v = y * z ∧ s • (u * z) - x * v = D.d w := by sorry
Formalization Note Transplanted verbatim from the Aether Catalog source Novelty/WeightMonodromyMassey.lean; the statement is byte-identical to the source declaration, elaborated with autoImplicit disabled in the platform environment.
Preamble
-- Thm stub generated from Novelty/WeightMonodromyMassey.lean
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_WeightMonodromyFormality
/-
Copyright (c) 2026. Released under Apache 2.0 license.
-/
/-!
# Massey products, purity and the obstruction to weight-monodromy
Companion to `Catalog/Novelty/WeightMonodromyFormality.lean`.
Two complementary results are proved.
* `massey_zero_of_formality` : in any strictly formal dg-algebra (i.e. one admitting a
`StrictFormalityData`) every triple Massey product which is defined contains `0`. The
mechanism is that the primitives can be chosen inside the acyclic ideal, which is absorbing.
* `massey_zero_of_weightPure` : the same conclusion directly from purity of the weight grading,
by a *weight* argument: a Massey representative of cohomological degree `p + q + r - 1`
necessarily has weight `p + q + r`, and purity kills everything off the diagonal.
The primitives are moreover produced explicitly as bihomogeneous components.
* `not_weightPure_of_massey` : contrapositive. A space whose cohomology algebra carries a
genuinely non-vanishing triple Massey product cannot have a pure weight grading; this is the
algebraic shadow of the non-formal rigid-analytic surfaces, which are therefore obstructions
to the naive weight-monodromy purity in the corresponding dg-algebra model.
-/
open WeightMonodromy
variable {k A : Type*} [Field k] [Ring A] [Algebra k A]
variable {𝒜 : ℤ × ℤ → Submodule k A} [GradedAlgebra 𝒜] {D : WeightedDGA 𝒜}Formal statement
theorem WeightMonodromy.massey_zero_of_formality(F : StrictFormalityData D) {x y z : A}
(hx : x ∈ F.sub) (hz : z ∈ F.sub)
(hxy_sub : x * y ∈ F.sub) (hyz_sub : y * z ∈ F.sub)
(hxy_d : D.d (x * y) = 0) (hyz_d : D.d (y * z) = 0)
(hxy_ex : ∃ c, x * y = D.d c) (hyz_ex : ∃ c, y * z = D.d c) (s : k)
(hcocycle : ∀ u v : A, D.d u = x * y → D.d v = y * z →
D.d (s • (u * z) - x * v) = 0) :
∃ u v w : A, D.d u = x * y ∧ D.d v = y * z ∧ s • (u * z) - x * v = D.d w := by sorrySource