Leopoldt's conjecture holds in CM fields for odd
OpenLeopoldt.leopoldt_CMThis is Theorem 1 of the source, the conjecture it sets out to prove.
Let be an odd prime and let be a CM number field, that is a totally complex quadratic extension of its maximal real subfield . Write for the units, for the semilocal units at , for the diagonal embedding, and
for the -adic closure of the global units. The Leopoldt defect is
The assertion is that it vanishes:
Equivalently, the -rank of the -adic closure of the units attains Dirichlet's -rank : units that are independent over remain independent after the diagonal embedding into the completions at the primes above . For CM fields this is equivalent to the non-vanishing of the -adic regulator of .
Leopoldt's conjecture is known for abelian extensions of by Brumer's 1967 theorem, and open in general; the CM case stated here is claimed by the source, an unrefereed preprint. By Iwasawa's theorem the defect measures the excess -rank of the Galois group of the maximal -abelian -ramified extension, , so vanishing of the defect pins that rank down exactly and, for the underlying totally real field, rules out non-cyclotomic -extensions.
Formalization Note Oddness of is stated as being an odd natural number alongside the primality assumption. The defect subtracts in and so truncates, but since the -rank never exceeds the -rank the truncation is never triggered, and the conclusion is equivalent to equality of the two ranks. The statement has no content when Dirichlet's rank is , that is for imaginary quadratic , and genuine content for every other CM field.
import Definitions.Def_LeopoldtDefect open NumberField
namespace Leopoldt
theorem leopoldt_CM (p : ℕ) [Fact p.Prime] (hp : Odd p)
(K : Type*) [Field K] [NumberField K] [IsCMField K] :
LeopoldtConjecture p K := by sorry
end LeopoldtRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5
Read-back. Fix a natural number carrying the instance-level assumption that is prime, together with an explicit hypothesis (so is an odd prime; is excluded, and no further condition on is imposed). Fix a type in an arbitrary universe, equipped with a field structure and with the assumption that is a number field (a finite-dimensional extension of , in particular of characteristic zero), and with the further class assumption that is a CM field, which unfolds to: every infinite place of is complex, and is a degree- extension of its maximal real subfield
Under these hypotheses the theorem asserts a single equation between natural numbers, spelled out below.
The objects involved, unfolded. Let be the ring of integers of . Let
be the set of nonzero primes of whose ideal contains the image of the integer — i.e. the primes above — regarded as a subtype; the bundle also supplies a proof that is finite. Nothing in the definitions requires to be nonempty: if it were empty, all the groups below would be trivial groups. For each , let be the -adic completion of and its valuation subring (the elements of valuation ), and put
the (dependent) product of the unit groups of these local integer rings, an abelian group carrying the product topology, where each is topologised as a subspace of via and carries the subspace topology from .
Let
be the diagonal group homomorphism induced componentwise by the canonical algebra maps, and let be its image subgroup (the image of the whole unit group, torsion included). For each natural number let be the image subgroup of the -st power map on . Define
the intersection, over all (so over exponents ), of the subgroups of generated by together with the -st powers; since is abelian, each such join is the set of products with , .
Next, for a natural number and a subgroup of an abelian topological group , define
where denotes the -adic integers, means functions from an -element index set to with the product topology and its additive group structure (written multiplicatively in the code), and is required only to be a continuous injective homomorphism of abstract groups landing inside — no -linearity, no closed image, no topological embedding onto its image is demanded. The supremum is taken in ; the defining set always contains (the trivial homomorphism from the trivial group qualifies) and is bounded above by , so is the largest such , and in particular always.
The assertion. Writing for the unit rank of (Dirichlet's rank, with truncated natural-number subtraction) and , define the defect
where is truncated subtraction on (it yields whenever ). The theorem states
which, because of the truncation, is exactly the inequality
there exists a natural number with and an injective continuous group homomorphism from into whose image lies inside — or else , in which case the equation holds automatically. No lower bound on beyond this is asserted, and no claim of equality between and is made.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).