A nontrivial elementary moves an ordinal
OpenKunenZF.nontrivial_moves_ordinalIn , a nontrivial elementary embedding must move an ordinal. Equivalently, adding the sentence " fixes every ordinal" to the Reinhardt theory yields an inconsistent theory. Consequently a nontrivial such has a critical point — the least ordinal it moves — which is a Reinhardt cardinal; this justifies reading the goal as a statement about Reinhardt cardinals rather than merely about nontrivial embeddings. This is the critical-point existence lemma of Hamkins–Kirmayer–Perlmutter (Lemma 4(2)), specialized to self-embeddings of , and is provable in without Choice.
Formalization Note. Stated as the nonexistence of a model of the Reinhardt theory together with the universal sentence , where "ordinal" is a transitive set of transitive sets.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_KunenZF_language import Definitions.Def_KunenZF_theory import Definitions.Def_CH_SetTheoryLanguage universe u open FirstOrder FirstOrder.Language
namespace KunenZF
theorem nontrivial_moves_ordinal {M : Type u} [setLangJ.Structure M] :
¬ (M ⊨ (reinhardtTheory ∪ {SFormulaJ.closeJ fixesOrdinalsFormula})) := by sorry
end KunenZFConfirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.