Proposition 6, PDF p. 21 — the crowdfunding option lowers the expected VC investment level iff e1 ≥ R0 and Δa > 0, and otherwise raises it
ProvedCrowdfundVC.Effects.proposition6Compare the expected VC investment level, with respect to the unconditional belief , in the two settings. Without crowdfunding the startup offers (Proposition 1) and the level is . With crowdfunding it offers (Proposition 4), and the level is computed along VC's decisions: if VC invests at , otherwise the average of the post-campaign levels after and with probabilities , .
Assume , , , , , , and Assumption (I), . Write and for the two levels. Then:
- if , , and , crowdfunding reduces the level: ;
- if and , crowdfunding raises the level: ;
- if , there is no investment without crowdfunding at any share — for every — while .
In short, when and ,
This is the paper's main finding on VC investment: crowdfunding lowers the expected investment exactly when a startup that VC would fund anyway prefers to wait for the campaign, and otherwise it raises it.
Formalization Note "Raises" is weak in case 2: at both levels equal ; it is strict in case 3. The hypotheses , and (on the whole theorem) and , (on case 1 only) are not in the paper and are each needed: at VC's threshold is not ; with the threshold can be negative; with the share can exceed ; at (or ) VC need not wait at and in case 1. The paper's case " or " is split into cases 2 and 3.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_CrowdfundVC_Effects_Model
namespace CrowdfundVC.Effects
/-- Proposition 6 (p. 21). If `e1 ≥ R0` and `Δa > 0` (and the signal is informative, `ρ > 0`, and
`p1 < 1`), the crowdfunding option strictly reduces the expected VC investment level; if `e1 ≥ R0`
and `Δa ≤ 0`, it (weakly) raises it; if `e1 < R0`, there is no investment
without crowdfunding at any share in `[0, 1]`, and the expected level with crowdfunding is
positive. Without crowdfunding the startup offers `αᵒ = R0/e1` (Proposition 1), with crowdfunding `αᶜ`
(Proposition 4). -/
theorem proposition6 (P : Params)
(hRf0 : 0 ≤ P.Rf) (hRfR0 : P.Rf < P.R0) (hR0Rs : P.R0 < P.Rs) (hK0 : 0 < P.K)
(hKR0 : P.K < P.R0) (hρ0 : 0 ≤ P.ρ) (hρ1 : P.ρ ≤ 1) (hβ0 : 0 ≤ P.β) (hβ1 : P.β < 1)
(hp2 : 0 ≤ P.p2) (hp12 : P.p2 ≤ P.p1) (hp1 : P.p1 ≤ 1) (hpa0 : 0 ≤ P.pa) (hpa1 : P.pa ≤ 1)
(hea : 0 < ea P) (hI : P.R0 ≤ e1S P) :
(0 < P.ρ → P.p1 < 1 →
P.R0 ≤ e1 P → 0 < deltaA P → invLevelCF P (alphaC P) < invLevelNoCF P (P.R0 / e1 P)) ∧
(P.R0 ≤ e1 P → deltaA P ≤ 0 → invLevelNoCF P (P.R0 / e1 P) ≤ invLevelCF P (alphaC P)) ∧
(e1 P < P.R0 →
(∀ α : ℝ, 0 ≤ α → α ≤ 1 → invLevelNoCF P α = 0) ∧ 0 < invLevelCF P (alphaC P)) := by sorry
end CrowdfundVC.Effects
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.