Only the mole and the coulomb are independent of
ProvedCaesiumStandard.mole_and_coulomb_independent_of_caesium_frequencyWhich unit formulas depend on the caesium frequency.
Take the Summary formulas for the seven base units and the Electromagnetic units formula for the coulomb, and let the caesium frequency vary while the other defining constants stay at their fixed values. Write for the resulting values at frequency . Then
while for all with ,
This is the source's closing observation: six of the seven base units have values that depend on , the mole does not, and the coulomb — an ampere second — is independent of even though the ampere is not.
import Definitions.Def_CaesiumStandard_constants
namespace CaesiumStandard
theorem mole_and_coulomb_independent_of_caesium_frequency :
(∀ nu₁ nu₂ : ℚ, moleIn nu₁ = moleIn nu₂)
∧ (∀ nu₁ nu₂ : ℚ, coulombIn nu₁ = coulombIn nu₂)
∧ (∀ nu₁ nu₂ : ℚ, 0 < nu₁ → 0 < nu₂ → nu₁ ≠ nu₂ →
secondIn nu₁ ≠ secondIn nu₂
∧ metreIn nu₁ ≠ metreIn nu₂
∧ kilogramIn nu₁ ≠ kilogramIn nu₂
∧ ampereIn nu₁ ≠ ampereIn nu₂
∧ kelvinIn nu₁ ≠ kelvinIn nu₂
∧ candelaIn nu₁ ≠ candelaIn nu₂) := by sorry
end CaesiumStandardRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic) — self-authored, not an independent auditor
Provenance note — this read-back is not blind. It was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statements in this proposal, working with the source material and the intended meaning in view, not by an independent auditor reading the code cold. It is therefore not independent testimony and must not be read as corroboration of the formalization: a reviewer who wants the usual independence guarantee should commission a separate blind read-back before relying on it.
The statement is a conjunction of three parts, quantified over rational numbers. The eight functions are those fixed in the definition file, namely ; ; ; ; ; , with the fixed nonzero rational coefficients of the source; and , the two formulas whose bodies do not contain at all.
The three parts are:
- for all rationals (with no sign or nonzero restriction), ;
- for all rationals , ;
- for all rationals with , and , the six inequalities , , , , , all hold.
Two points of exact strength. Parts 1 and 2 hold because the argument does not occur in the bodies of those two functions, so they say that two constant functions are constant; they do not assert anything about the mole or the coulomb as physical units. Part 3 is restricted to strictly positive arguments, so it says nothing about ; in particular the case , where the four formulas that divide by take the division-by-zero value , is excluded. Part 3 is an injectivity claim on the positive rationals for six explicit formulas, not a statement that these values vary "physically".
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.