Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Transfer of a center-direction tube cover to every source witness

Open
FalconerPath.middle_witness_center

by dangnguyen · Nov 5, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

falconertube-geometrywitness-robustness

Let k∈Nk\in\mathbb Nk∈N and s,q,ζ,L,a,C∈Rs,q,\zeta,L,a,C\in\mathbb Rs,q,ζ,L,a,C∈R. For every j∈Nj\in\mathbb Nj∈N, let XjX_jXj​ consist of Nj∈NN_j\in\mathbb NNj​∈N, probabilities νj,ρj\nu_j,\rho_jνj​,ρj​ on Rk+1\mathbb R^{k+1}Rk+1, a translation vjv_jvj​, a real function mjm_jmj​, an error ej≥0e_j\ge0ej​≥0, and a Borel relation GjG_jGj​. Assume L,a>0L,a>0L,a>0, both supports lie in B‾(0,L)\overline B(0,L)B(0,L), and ∥x−z∥≥a\|x-z\|\ge a∥x−z∥≥a for every x∈supp⁡νjx\in\operatorname{supp}\nu_jx∈suppνj​ and z∈supp⁡ρjz\in\operatorname{supp}\rho_jz∈suppρj​. The measure ρj\rho_jρj​ is carried by the half-open unit grid cell Q(vj,0,0)Q(v_j,0,0)Q(vj​,0,0). On [0,1][0,1][0,1], mjm_jmj​ is nondecreasing and (k+1)(k+1)(k+1)-Lipschitz, mj(0)=0m_j(0)=0mj​(0)=0, and mj(u)≥su−ejm_j(u)\ge su-e_jmj​(u)≥su−ej​. Put Rj=2NjR_j=2^{N_j}Rj​=2Nj​. For every ℓ≤Nj\ell\le N_jℓ≤Nj​ and cell Q=Q(vj,ℓ,i)Q=Q(v_j,\ell,i)Q=Q(vj​,ℓ,i) with positive mass, require Rj−mj(ℓ/Nj)−ej≤ρj(Q)≤Rj−mj(ℓ/Nj)+ejR_j^{-m_j(\ell/N_j)-e_j}\le\rho_j(Q)\le R_j^{-m_j(\ell/N_j)+e_j}Rj−mj​(ℓ/Nj​)−ej​​≤ρj​(Q)≤Rj−mj​(ℓ/Nj​)+ej​​. For every 0≤ℓ≤h≤Nj0\le\ell\le h\le N_j0≤ℓ≤h≤Nj​ and nested cells Q′=Q(vj,h,i′)⊆Q=Q(vj,ℓ,i)Q'=Q(v_j,h,i')\subseteq Q=Q(v_j,\ell,i)Q′=Q(vj​,h,i′)⊆Q=Q(vj​,ℓ,i) with ρj(Q′)>0\rho_j(Q')>0ρj​(Q′)>0, require Rj−(mj(h/Nj)−mj(ℓ/Nj))−ej≤ρj(Q′)/ρj(Q)≤Rj−(mj(h/Nj)−mj(ℓ/Nj))+ejR_j^{-(m_j(h/N_j)-m_j(\ell/N_j))-e_j}\le\rho_j(Q')/\rho_j(Q)\le R_j^{-(m_j(h/N_j)-m_j(\ell/N_j))+e_j}Rj−(mj​(h/Nj​)−mj​(ℓ/Nj​))−ej​​≤ρj​(Q′)/ρj​(Q)≤Rj−(mj​(h/Nj​)−mj​(ℓ/Nj​))+ej​​. At Nj=0N_j=0Nj​=0 real division uses 0/0=00/0=00/0=0. Assume Gj⊆supp⁡νj×supp⁡ρjG_j\subseteq\operatorname{supp}\nu_j\times\operatorname{supp}\rho_jGj​⊆suppνj​×suppρj​. Define λj,z=(πz)#(νj∣{x:(x,z)∈Gj})\lambda_{j,z}=(\pi_z)_\#(\nu_j|_{\{x:(x,z)\in G_j\}})λj,z​=(πz​)#​(νj​∣{x:(x,z)∈Gj​}​), where πz(x)=∥x−z∥−1(x−z)\pi_z(x)=\|x-z\|^{-1}(x-z)πz​(x)=∥x−z∥−1(x−z) with value zero at x=zx=zx=z. For ρj\rho_jρj​-almost every zzz, every w∈Skw\in S^kw∈Sk and every 2−Nj≤u≤12^{-N_j}\le u\le12−Nj​≤u≤1 with u>0u>0u>0 satisfy λj,z(B(w,u))≤Rjejuq\lambda_{j,z}(B(w,u))\le R_j^{e_j}u^qλj,z​(B(w,u))≤Rjej​​uq. Also, for ρj\rho_jρj​-almost every zzz, every v∈Skv\in S^kv∈Sk and the same radii satisfy λj,z{w∈Sk:∣⟨w,v⟩∣≤u}≤[Cuζ]+\lambda_{j,z}\{w\in S^k:|\langle w,v\rangle|\le u\}\le[Cu^\zeta]_+λj,z​{w∈Sk:∣⟨w,v⟩∣≤u}≤[Cuζ]+​. Here [u]+=max⁡(u,0)[u]_+=\max(u,0)[u]+​=max(u,0) in the extended nonnegative reals. These are the conditions encoded by Xj∈RadialClassData(k,s,q,ζ,L,a,C)X_j\in\mathrm{RadialClassData}(k,s,q,\zeta,L,a,C)Xj​∈RadialClassData(k,s,q,ζ,L,a,C). Assume Nj→∞N_j\to\inftyNj​→∞. For real A,BA,BA,B with 0<A<B<10<A<B<10<A<B<1, put Dj=Rj−(B−A)D_j=R_j^{-(B-A)}Dj​=Rj−(B−A)​, dj=⌊ANj⌋d_j=\lfloor AN_j\rfloordj​=⌊ANj​⌋, bj=⌊BNj⌋b_j=\lfloor BN_j\rfloorbj​=⌊BNj​⌋, and Qj,i=Q(vj,dj,i)Q_{j,i}=Q(v_j,d_j,i)Qj,i​=Q(vj​,dj​,i). Here Q(v,d,i)={z:vr+ir2−d≤zr<vr+(ir+1)2−d for every r}Q(v,d,i)=\{z:v_r+i_r2^{-d}\le z_r<v_r+(i_r+1)2^{-d}\text{ for every }r\}Q(v,d,i)={z:vr​+ir​2−d≤zr​<vr​+(ir​+1)2−d for every r}. Write cj,ic_{j,i}cj,i​ for its center and μj,i=(z↦2dj(z−cj,i))#(ρj(Qj,i)−1ρj∣Qj,i)\mu_{j,i}=(z\mapsto2^{d_j}(z-c_{j,i}))_\#(\rho_j(Q_{j,i})^{-1}\rho_j|_{Q_{j,i}})μj,i​=(z↦2dj​(z−cj,i​))#​(ρj​(Qj,i​)−1ρj​∣Qj,i​​). Assume B<2AB<2AB<2A and fix real K,c>0K,c>0K,c>0. Write TL(w,b,r)={y:∥y∥≤L, dist⁡(y,b+Rw)≤r}\mathcal T_L(w,b,r)=\{y:\|y\|\le L,\ \operatorname{dist}(y,b+\mathbb Rw)\le r\}TL​(w,b,r)={y:∥y∥≤L, dist(y,b+Rw)≤r} and let B(μ,L,C,δ,q,c)\mathcal B(\mu,L,C,\delta,q,c)B(μ,L,C,δ,q,c) be the set of w∈Skw\in S^kw∈Sk for which some finite anchor set F⊂Rk+1F\subset\mathbb R^{k+1}F⊂Rk+1 has #F≤δ−q−c\#F\le\delta^{-q-c}#F≤δ−q−c and μ(⋃b∈FTL(w,b,Cδ))≥δc\mu(\bigcup_{b\in F}\mathcal T_L(w,b,C\delta))\ge\delta^cμ(⋃b∈F​TL​(w,b,Cδ))≥δc. Eventually in jjj, for every iii with ρj(Qj,i)>0\rho_j(Q_{j,i})>0ρj​(Qj,i​)>0, every x∈supp⁡νjx\in\operatorname{supp}\nu_jx∈suppνj​, every z∈Qj,i∩supp⁡ρjz\in Q_{j,i}\cap\operatorname{supp}\rho_jz∈Qj,i​∩suppρj​, and every finite anchor set F⊂Rk+1F\subset\mathbb R^{k+1}F⊂Rk+1, if #F≤Dj−q−c\#F\le D_j^{-q-c}#F≤Dj−q−c​ and μj,i(⋃b∈FTk+2(πcj,i(x),b,KDj))≥Djc\mu_{j,i}(\bigcup_{b\in F}\mathcal T_{k+2}(\pi_{c_{j,i}}(x),b,KD_j))\ge D_j^cμj,i​(⋃b∈F​Tk+2​(πcj,i​​(x),b,KDj​))≥Djc​, then πz(x)∈B(μj,i,k+2,K+1,Dj,q,c)\pi_z(x)\in\mathcal B(\mu_{j,i},k+2,K+1,D_j,q,c)πz​(x)∈B(μj,i​,k+2,K+1,Dj​,q,c).

Preamble
import Definitions.Def_FalconerPath_connect
open Set MeasureTheory Filter
open scoped ENNReal NNReal Topology
Formal statement
namespace FalconerPath
/-- Section 5, proof of Lemma 5.3, paragraph after (prep:witness-bad):
B<2A gives R^(-A)=o(D). Recenter tube axes in the bounded rescaled ball
and transfer a center-direction cover to ANY source witness, using width
K+1. Reverse directions are used consistently; tubes are unoriented.
This is only a geometric cover implication, with no angular mass bound. -/
theorem middle_witness_center {k : ℕ} (s q ζ L a C : ℝ)
    (X : ℕ → RadialClassData k s q ζ L a C)
    (hN : Tendsto (fun j => (X j).N) atTop atTop)
    (A B : ℝ) (hA : 0 < A) (hAB : A < B) (hB : B < 1) (hBA : B < 2*A)
    (K c : ℝ) (hK : 0 < K) (hc : 0 < c) :
    ∀ᶠ j in atTop,
      let D := (scale (X j).N)^(-(B-A))
      let d := contactDepths (X j).N A B 1
      ∀ i : Fin (k+1) → ℤ, 0 < (X j).ρ (dyadicCell (X j).v d i) →
      ∀ x ∈ (X j).ν.support, ∀ z ∈ dyadicCell (X j).v d i,
      z ∈ (X j).ρ.support → ∀ anchors : Finset (Space (k+1)),
        (anchors.card : ℝ) ≤ D^(-q-c) →
        ENNReal.ofReal (D^c) ≤ connectCellLaw (X j).ρ (X j).v d i
          (⋃ b ∈ anchors, tube ((k:ℝ)+2)
            (radial (connectCellCenter (X j).v d i) x) b (K*D)) →
        radial z x ∈ badDirections (connectCellLaw (X j).ρ (X j).v d i)
          ((k:ℝ)+2) (K+1) D q c := by sorry
end FalconerPath
Source
OpenAI, The Falconer distance conjecture in all dimensions, OpenAI Math Release preprint, September 23, 2026, https://github.com/openai/math/blob/adc7f1241b42e322a6451854ab7e4b4c146bf78a/preprints/The-Falconer-distance-conjecture-in-all-dimensions-September-23-2026/paper.pdf, Section 5, Lemma 5.3 (prep:one-scale), proof paragraph beginning with deletion of the pairs in (prep:witness-bad), through (prep:linearization-margin) and the center-direction robustness conclusion. B<2A gives R^(-A)=o(D), and recentering axes in the bounded rescaled ball allows arbitrary anchors before the width enlargement K+1.

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me