(11), p. 18 — in equilibrium the optimist's net Sharpe ratio θ₂⁽ᵒ⁾ = θ₁⁽ᵒ⁾ + γ is strictly positive
ProvedCostlyShort.ShortMarket.eq11_optimist_longFix one state of the economy (the time index is dropped) and an equilibrium in the sense of Definition 1 at that state (see the mission's definitions item): the volatilities of the two risky assets, the price of asset 1, the wealths of the optimist and the pessimist , their market prices of risk with (disagreement ), the lending yield and shorting cost per unit of volatility, and the agents' optimal wealth fractions . The equilibrium conditions are (7), optimality in (8), clearing of asset 1 and of the lending market (5), and the shorting cost (4) chosen as the least revenue maximizer (13).
Then the optimist's net Sharpe ratio on long positions is strictly positive:
Since asset 1 is in positive supply and the pessimist is short whenever the optimist is, the two agents cannot both be short; hence all shorting comes from the pessimist and the optimist is long at all times. This is what reduces the lending agent's revenue (10) to the pessimist's contribution.
Formalization Note The equilibrium is the predicate IsShortMarketEquilibrium of the definitions item. Its shorting-cost condition is the per-volatility revenue (10) maximized over , with the least maximizer selected as in (13); (11), (13) and (14) are not assumed — they are derived results of the paper (separate items of this mission). Consumption clearing and asset-2 clearing are not part of the predicate, which makes the statement more general.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_CostlyShort_ShortMarket_Setting
namespace CostlyShort.ShortMarket
theorem eq11_optimist_long {σ₁ σ₂ S₁ Wo Wp θ₁o θ₁p θ₂o θ₂p γ φ : ℝ} {po pp : ℝ × ℝ}
(hσ₁ : 0 < σ₁) (hσ₂ : 0 < σ₂) (hS₁ : 0 < S₁) (hWo : 0 < Wo) (hWp : 0 < Wp)
(hΔ : θ₁p ≤ θ₁o)
(heq : IsShortMarketEquilibrium σ₁ σ₂ S₁ Wo Wp θ₁o θ₁p θ₂o θ₂p γ φ po pp) :
0 < θ₂o := by sorry
end CostlyShort.ShortMarket
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.