Theorem 4 (Linear gap transfer) — from uniform coherent bounds, with the bounds (126) on
OpenMFHeisGibbs.Supplement.theorem_4Let be an arbitrary Hamiltonian on , , , and let be a finite family of self-adjoint jumps with for all and all , for some . Let be the OFT Lindbladian of these jumps with the Metropolis filter and width , and for a KMS filter let be the coherent Lindbladian of the same jumps with filter ; both keep the coherent correction. Let , and be as in (122), (123), (125), and let be the standard normal distribution function. Then:
- every (, both signs) is a KMS filter: it is continuous and ;
- is even, and ;
- let be a subspace of operators invariant under that contains or is KMS-orthogonal to , and contains an observable of positive variance, and let . If for some
then
- ;
- for finite ,
The theorem turns any spectral-gap lower bound for coherent Lindbladians that is uniform over the Gaussian filters into a gap lower bound for the Metropolis OFT Lindbladian, with every constant explicit; the paper applies it to the mean-field Heisenberg model in Corollary 6.
Formalization Note All Gibbs quantities (, , , , ) are those of the Gibbs state of at the same . "KMS filter" means continuity and the KMS relation without the normalization of (4), as Appendix B says. The bandwidth hypothesis is one-sided, as printed.
Differences from the source:
- encoding: ω_trn ∈ (0, ∞] → an extended nonnegative real ωt with 0 < ωt, region {ω | ofReal |ω| ≤ ωt}; the second bound of (126) for ω_trn < ∞ is stated for every real ωt > 0 at ofReal ωt; reason: same values, ∞ included
- encoding: the sign ± → a Boolean pm (true for +); reason: Lean convention; both signs are quantified
- encoding: the OFT integral (10) with K̂(ω) of (11) → its Bohr expansion Σ_{ν,μ} κ(ν,μ) K_ν† X K_μ; reason: the integrand expands to this finite sum of scalar integrals, so the map is the same
- encoding: a family {K^(a)}{a∈A} → a finite index type A; reason: L^h_C and L{F,σ} are sums over a (p.50), and Proposition 5 speaks of finite families
- encoding: the Dirichlet form E_L(O) = ⟨O, −L[O]⟩_ρ (24) → its real part Re⟨O, −L[O]⟩ρ; reason: L^h_C (Lemma 21) and L{F,σ} are KMS detailed balanced, so the form is real and the values coincide
- encoding: min_{x∈[−Λ,0]} |h(x)|² → sInf of the image of [−Λ, 0]; reason: Λ ≥ 0 and h_{ω,±} is continuous, so the infimum over the compact interval is attained and equals the minimum
import Definitions.Def_MFHeisGibbs_Supplement_GibbsH import Definitions.Def_MFHeisGibbs_Supplement_Transfer open Matrix open scoped ENNReal
namespace MFHeisGibbs
namespace Supplement
/-- **Theorem 4 (Linear gap transfer)**, (122)–(126), Raikovich, Mák, Czabán, Gilyén, arXiv:2610.06818
(version dated November 3, 2026, sha256 164d57ba…), p.53 (PDF 54), in the setting of Appendix B.1, p.50
(`0 < β < ∞`, `σ > 0`, `H` an arbitrary Hamiltonian on `H_n`).
Let `{K^(a)}_{a ∈ A}` be self-adjoint jumps with `K^(a)_ν = 0` for all `ν > Λ/β`, `Λ ≥ 0`. Then
(a) every `h_{ω,±}` is a KMS filter; (b) `w` is even; (c) `w(ω) = e^{−σ²/8} e^{−β|ω|/2}`; (d) for every
subspace `V` invariant under the Metropolis OFT Lindbladian `L_{F,σ}`, containing `I` or KMS-orthogonal
to `I`, with an observable of positive variance, every `ω_trn ∈ (0, ∞]` and `κ > 0` with (124),
`γ(L_{F,σ}, V) ≥ κ c_eff(ω_trn)`; (e), (f) the lower bounds (126) on `c_eff`.
**Formalization Note.** Both Lindbladians keep the coherent correction of (116). "KMS filter" for `h` is
`KMSRel` (continuity and the KMS relation, no normalization), as on p.50. The sign `±` is `pm : Bool`.
The Gibbs quantities are those of `H` at
the same `β`: the KMS inner product is the published `SysBathGibbs.kmsInner β H`. The second bound of (126) is stated for finite `ω_trn > 0` as `c_eff(ENNReal.ofReal ω_trn)`. The family
of jumps is finite (`Fintype A`), as `L^h_C = ∑_a` requires. -/
theorem theorem_4 {n : ℕ} (H : Op n) (hH : H.IsHermitian) (β : ℝ) (hβ : 0 < β) (s : ℝ) (hs : 0 < s)
{A : Type} [Fintype A] (K : A → Op n) (hK : ∀ a, (K a).IsHermitian) (Λ : ℝ) (hΛ : 0 ≤ Λ)
(hband : ∀ a, ∀ ν : ℝ, Λ / β < ν → bohrComp hH (K a) ν = 0) :
(∀ (ω : ℝ) (pm : Bool), KMSRel (hOm β s ω pm)) ∧
(∀ ω : ℝ, wM β s (-ω) = wM β s ω) ∧
(∀ ω : ℝ, wM β s ω = Real.exp (-s ^ 2 / 8) * Real.exp (-(β * |ω|) / 2)) ∧
(∀ (V : Submodule ℂ (Op n)) (ωt : ℝ≥0∞) (κ : ℝ),
(∀ X ∈ V, LFfam hH β s fM K X ∈ V) →
((1 : Op n) ∈ V ∨ ∀ X ∈ V, SysBathGibbs.kmsInner β H 1 X = 0) →
(∃ O ∈ V, 0 < gibbsVarH H β O) →
0 < ωt → 0 < κ →
(∀ O ∈ V, ∀ ω : ℝ, ENNReal.ofReal |ω| ≤ ωt → ∀ pm : Bool,
κ * minSqOn Λ (hOm β s ω pm) * gibbsVarH H β O ≤
dirichletH H β (LCh hH β (hOm β s ω pm) K) O) →
κ * ceff β s Λ ωt ≤ sectorGapH H β (LFfam hH β s fM K) (V : Set (Op n))) ∧
1 - normalCdf (max (s / 2) (Λ / (2 * s))) ≤ ceff β s Λ ⊤ ∧
(∀ ωt : ℝ, 0 < ωt →
ωt * β / (s * Real.sqrt (2 * Real.pi)) *
Real.exp (-(max Λ (β * ωt) + s ^ 2 / 2) ^ 2 / (2 * s ^ 2)) ≤
ceff β s Λ (ENNReal.ofReal ωt)) := by sorry
end Supplement
end MFHeisGibbs