A.2, eq. (19), p. 37 — g = g0 iff c_K/e = g − √(2c_Q g), and g > g0 iff c_K/e < g − √(2c_Q g)
ProvedOffGridStorage.TechChoice.eq_19_threshold_ratioenergy-storagep2o-batch-pfp2ap2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1threshold
Let , and , and write . Then
With the first equivalence is eq. (19): solving for the cost-to-efficiency ratio. The second is the form in which the proof of Theorem 2 uses it: a technology is profitable at backup cost exactly when its ratio lies below .
Formalization Note Eq. (19) is printed as a chain of equalities at the boundary ; the strict version is the one the surrounding prose relies on ("a lower means that the range of back-up costs for which the technology is suitable … is larger").
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_OffGridStorage_TechChoice_Model
Formal statement
namespace OffGridStorage.TechChoice
/-- A.2, eq. (19), p. 37: with `r = c_K/e`, the backup cost equals the threshold exactly when
`r = g - √(2 c_Q g)`, and exceeds it exactly when `r < g - √(2 c_Q g)`. -/
theorem eq_19_threshold_ratio (cQ r g : ℝ) (hcQ : 0 < cQ) (hr : 0 ≤ r) (hg : 2 * cQ < g) :
(g0ratio cQ r = g ↔ r = g - Real.sqrt (2 * cQ * g)) ∧
(g0ratio cQ r < g ↔ r < g - Real.sqrt (2 * cQ * g)) := by sorry
end OffGridStorage.TechChoice
Source
Kaps, Marinesi & Netessine, When Should the Off-grid Sun Shine at Night?, SSRN 3761397 (version of May 11, 2023), p. 37, Appendix A.2 (proof of Theorem 2), eq. (19)
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.