Proof of Proposition 5, p. 17 — the profits are equal at v̂_a and v_s + (7+3√5)B/2; acquihiring wins in between
ProvedAcquihiringMonopsony.PrivateInfo.profit_comparison_rootsacquihiringp2o-batch-pfp2ap2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1private-information
Let and write and . Compare the acquirer's profit under acquihiring, , with its direct-hiring profit from Lemma 5. Then
the two profits are equal exactly when or , and
so the upper root lies outside the range allowed in §6.
This is the computation behind Proposition 5: within the parameter range of §6 only the lower root matters.
Formalization Note Only is assumed; the statement is pure algebra in and holds without the remaining standing assumptions.
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_AcquihiringMonopsony_PrivateInfo_Model
Formal statement
namespace AcquihiringMonopsony.PrivateInfo
theorem profit_comparison_roots (P : Params) (hB : 0 < P.B) :
((P.va - P.vs + P.B) ^ 2 / (9 * P.B) < P.va - P.vs ↔
vHat P < P.va ∧ P.va < P.vs + (7 + 3 * Real.sqrt 5) / 2 * P.B) ∧
((P.va - P.vs + P.B) ^ 2 / (9 * P.B) = P.va - P.vs ↔
P.va = vHat P ∨ P.va = P.vs + (7 + 3 * Real.sqrt 5) / 2 * P.B) ∧
P.vs + 2 * P.B < P.vs + (7 + 3 * Real.sqrt 5) / 2 * P.B := by sorry
end AcquihiringMonopsony.PrivateInfo
Source
Bar-Isaac, Johnson, Nocke, Acquihiring for Monopsony Power, CRC TR 224 DP No. 500 (Jan. 2024), p. 17 (PDF 18), proof of Proposition 5, first paragraph
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.