Monotone proposition-uniform lifting schemas are conservative
ProvedTranscendenceTower.UniformityPlatform.uniformity_monotone_dichotomyA monotone lifting schema that treats all propositions alike proves no new sentence of the base language. Uniformity and novelty are incompatible, and already in the monotone case, where the extension is unique automatically.
Four parts.
-
The dichotomy. If the base theory contains no context machinery and the schema's consequents are closed under substitution, then either is inconsistent or every base sentence it proves was already a consequence of .
-
Conservativity. The same statement as an equality of sets: the extension meets the base language in exactly the base consequences of .
-
The copy schema is proposition-uniform. Its consequents are the sentences , and substituting inside one produces another.
-
The copy schema is consistent, witnessed by the canonical valuation in which says exactly what says.
Parts 3 and 4 are not decoration. Without them the dichotomy could hold vacuously, constraining an empty class of schemas; together they exhibit the intended example satisfying every hypothesis.
The informal claim being made precise is that a rule earns the name rule by being indifferent to which proposition it lifts, and that this indifference is exactly what prevents it from delivering a particular new fact. If it delivers , then under substitution it must deliver every substitution instance of , and those are jointly unsatisfiable whenever is not already forced.
Limits. The result is about monotone schemas; the defeasible case needs the trichotomy, where uniqueness can fail instead. Context-freeness of is essential and not a technicality: a base theory that already speaks of contexts can supply a premise the schema exports, and non-conservativity then follows for reasons having nothing to do with lifting. Nothing here says a lifting schema is useless — it says that whatever content one carries must come from somewhere other than its uniformity.
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerContextUniformity set_option autoImplicit false open TranscendenceTower.UniformityPlatform
theorem TranscendenceTower.UniformityPlatform.uniformity_monotone_dichotomy (A C : Type) :
(∀ T Γ : Set (CForm A C), (∀ p ∈ T, IsBase p) → PropUniform Γ →
Consistent (T ∪ Γ) →
∀ φ : CForm A C, IsBase φ → φ ∈ Cn (T ∪ Γ) → φ ∈ Cn T)
∧ (∀ T Γ : Set (CForm A C), (∀ p ∈ T, IsBase p) → PropUniform Γ →
Consistent (T ∪ Γ) →
{φ : CForm A C | IsBase φ ∧ φ ∈ Cn (T ∪ Γ)}
= {φ : CForm A C | IsBase φ ∧ φ ∈ Cn T})
∧ PropUniform (copySchema A C)
∧ (∀ atomv : A → Bool, Models (copySchema A C) (canonVal atomv)) := by sorry