Proposition 4 — comparison of calibrated regulation mechanisms
DisprovedWangGreenTech.Regulation.proposition_4Let satisfy , , , , , , and . Signals and the common fundamental are real. Conditional on signal , the specified posterior is uniform on . Followers form a unit-mass population on ; the leader has zero population mass. Both choose action 1 at indifference.
The prescribed endogenous adoption threshold is , with aggregate . Define
The development set is and .
For a fixed regulation probability , put and
Set and .
Suppose , and calibrate the two regulation mechanisms by
which makes the period-2 adoption cutoffs equal, . With all these primitives fixed, there exists a real such that for every ,
This is the paper's comparison of development incentives under equally effective adoption incentives.
Formalization Note This faithful item retains and a finite real comparison threshold, possibly negative. Finding F1 gives a counterexample on that permitted boundary: the cutoffs coincide for every , so no finite works. It remains the mission goal; the corrected item adds a strict payoff gap. The existential comparison threshold precedes the quantifier over . The Lean statement expands the posterior integrals and development-set infima for a self-contained blind audit; a separate, fully proved verification lemma checks that this expansion is definitionally identical to the canonical cutoff comparison.
import Definitions.Def_WangGreenTech_Regulation_Policies set_option autoImplicit false
namespace WangGreenTech.Regulation
open MeasureTheory Set
theorem proposition_4 (ε b q r f₁ fL fH mL mH qhat : ℝ)
(hε : 0 < ε) (hb0 : 0 ≤ b) (hq0 : 0 ≤ q) (hq1 : q < 1) (hr : 0 < r)
(hf₁ : 0 < f₁) (hfL : 0 < fL) (hfH : fL ≤ fH) (hm : mL ≤ mH) (hmH : mH ≤ 0)
(hqh0 : 0 < qhat) (hqh1 : qhat < 1) (hb : b ≤ 2 * ε)
(hcal : qhat = q + (1 - q) / (r + 1)) :
let t : ℝ := b / 2 + fL - fH + r / (r + 1) * (1 - q) * (fH - mL)
let that : ℝ := b / 2 + fL - (1 - qhat) * mL - qhat * fH
let A : ℝ → ℝ → ℝ := fun cutoff θ => min 1 (max 0 ((θ + ε - cutoff) / (2 * ε)))
let E : ℝ → (ℝ → ℝ) → ℝ := fun x h =>
∫ θ, h θ ∂((ENNReal.ofReal (2 * ε))⁻¹ • volume.restrict (Icc (x - ε) (x + ε)))
let UD : ℝ → ℝ → ℝ := fun lam x => E x (fun θ =>
lam - f₁ + mL + θ - b * A t θ + (q + (1 - q) * (A t θ) ^ r) * (mH - mL))
let UF : ℝ → ℝ → ℝ := fun lam x => E x (fun θ =>
lam - f₁ + θ - b * A that θ + qhat * mH + (1 - qhat) * mL)
∃ lamhat : ℝ, ∀ lam : ℝ, 0 ≤ lam →
(sInf {x : ℝ | 0 ≤ UD lam x} ≤ sInf {x : ℝ | 0 ≤ UF lam x} ↔ lam ≤ lamhat) := by sorry
end WangGreenTech.Regulation
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5
The statement fixes ten real parameters and assumes all of the following:
- ;
- ;
- ;
- ;
- ;
- and ;
- ;
- ;
- the calibration identity
Given and , this identity already forces . Everything else in the statement is defined locally from these parameters; no named definition from the imported bundle appears.
Two thresholds are defined:
For a cutoff and a real , a clamped linear ramp is defined:
It is for , rises linearly to on , and is for . This is the value at of the distribution function of the uniform law on .
For a real and a function , an averaging operator is defined:
This is the expectation of for uniform on , computed as a Bochner integral.
Two payoff functions of and are then defined:
In , the power is the real power with real exponent , applied to a base in .
The conclusion is that there exists a real number such that for every ,
Some consequences are immediate from the form of this claim:
- is not required to be nonnegative.
- The equivalence is only asserted for ; nothing is said about negative .
- No real satisfies for every . The statement therefore implies that the set of at which the left-hand comparison holds is either empty or exactly . In particular, the comparison fails for all sufficiently large .
- If that set is empty, any negative witnesses the claim, so is then not unique.
Degenerate and default-value cases:
- No junk divisions. The hypotheses permit , which removes the ramp penalty terms, as well as and , which makes the factor vanish. They also permit any , including non-integers, and . Since and , the divisions by and by are genuine, and the averaging interval is nondegenerate with a probability measure. There is no natural-number subtraction and there are no empty or one-element types.
- No junk integrals. Each integrand is continuous and bounded in on the bounded interval ; the power is continuous on , with , because . So none of the integrals falls back to the default value used for non-integrable functions.
- No junk infima. The real infimum would return the default value if a set were empty or unbounded below. This does not happen here. In each payoff, averages to and every other term is bounded, so and equal plus a bounded function of . Hence each set is nonempty and bounded below, and both infima are genuine.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.