Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Aether Catalog definitions — Bridges_NeuralProofMining

Definition
Bridges_NeuralProofMining

by raver1975 · Sep 17, 2026 · Mathlib c5ea003 (Lean v4.30.0)

aether-catalogbridges

Definition bundle for the Aether Catalog module Bridges.NeuralProofMining, transplanted by skeleton subtraction; supplies the types and constants the catalog's theorems import.

Definition code
-- Def bundle generated from Bridges/NeuralProofMining.lean by skeleton subtraction
import Mathlib
/-
Copyright (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Released under Apache 2.0 license as described in the file LICENSE.
-/

/-!
# Neural Proof Mining: Tactic Monoid Representation Theory

This file establishes the mathematical foundations of **neural proof mining** by
connecting representation theory of finite monoids to certified robustness of
neural theorem provers and proof search complexity bounds.

## Main Results

### Part I: Tactic Shape Monoid
* `TacticTrace.depth_one` : The identity trace has depth 0
* `TacticTrace.depth_mul` : Trace depth is additive under composition
* `TacticTrace.depth_pow` : Trace depth scales linearly under powering

### Part II: Monoid Representations and Cayley Faithfulness
* `cayley_left_action_faithful` : Left regular action of any monoid is faithful
* `faithful_rep_injective_of_distinct` : Faithful representations separate elements
* `rep_dimension_lower_bound` : Faithful representations need dimension ≥ 1

### Part III: Lipschitz Goal Embeddings
* `lipschitz_embedding_dist_bound` : Lipschitz embeddings preserve distance bounds
* `certified_robustness_radius` : Certified adversarial robustness from Lipschitz

### Part IV: Proof Depth Bounds and Stratification
* `depth_strata_cover` : Goals belong to their depth stratum
* `depth_strata_disjoint` : Distinct strata are disjoint
* `depth_complexity_tradeoff` : Pigeonhole bound on stratum sizes

## Bridge
Connects representation theory of finite monoids to certified robustness
in neural theorem proving and to proof search complexity bounds relevant
to post-quantum cryptographic hardness.
-/

noncomputable section

open Finset

namespace NeuralProofMining

/-! ## Part I: The Tactic Shape Monoid -/

/-- A tactic shape represents an abstract proof tactic with a numeric identifier
    and an arity (number of subgoals generated). This is the alphabet of proof. -/
structure TacticShape where
  /-- Unique identifier for the tactic type -/
  id : ℕ
  /-- Number of subgoals generated by this tactic -/
  arity : ℕ
  deriving DecidableEq, Inhabited, Repr

/-- A tactic trace is a sequence of tactic applications, forming elements
    of the free monoid on tactic shapes. The monoid operation is concatenation,
    representing sequential composition of proof strategies.

    Bridge: This is the fundamental algebraic object connecting proof theory
    to representation theory — the free monoid whose representations govern
    proof search complexity. -/
@[ext]
structure TacticTrace where
  /-- The ordered sequence of tactic shapes applied -/
  steps : List TacticShape
  deriving DecidableEq

instance : Inhabited TacticTrace := ⟨⟨[]⟩⟩
instance : One TacticTrace := ⟨⟨[]⟩⟩
instance : Mul TacticTrace := ⟨fun t₁ t₂ => ⟨t₁.steps ++ t₂.steps⟩⟩

@[simp] lemma TacticTrace.mul_steps (a b : TacticTrace) :
    (a * b).steps = a.steps ++ b.steps := rfl

@[simp] lemma TacticTrace.one_steps : (1 : TacticTrace).steps = [] := rfl

instance : Monoid TacticTrace where
  one_mul t := by ext; simp
  mul_one t := by ext; simp
  mul_assoc a b c := by ext; simp [List.append_assoc]

/-- The depth of a tactic trace: the number of tactic applications.
    This is a monoid homomorphism to (ℕ, +).

    Bridge: Depth measures proof complexity in the representation-theoretic
    framework, connecting to neural network layer depth and lattice
    dimension in post-quantum cryptographic proof-of-work. -/
def TacticTrace.depth (t : TacticTrace) : ℕ := t.steps.length

/-- The total arity of a trace: sum of arities of all tactic shapes.
    Measures the total branching complexity of a proof. -/
def TacticTrace.totalArity (t : TacticTrace) : ℕ :=
  (t.steps.map TacticShape.arity).sum


/-
**Depth Additivity**: Trace depth is additive under composition.
    Composing proofs adds their depths — a fundamental homomorphism
    from the tactic monoid to (ℕ, +).

    Bridge: connects proof composition (monoid structure) to proof
    complexity (additive structure), establishing that depth is a
    representation-theoretic invariant.
-/

/-
**Depth Power Scaling**: The depth of t^n is n times the depth of t.
    Proof complexity scales linearly under iteration.

    Impact: Gives O(n · d) complexity for iterated proof strategies
    of base depth d, directly relevant to certified_robustness of
    bounded-depth neural provers.
-/

/-
**Arity Additivity**: Total arity is additive under trace composition.
-/

/-
**Arity-Depth Bound**: Total arity is bounded by depth times maximum arity.
    If each tactic generates at most k subgoals, a trace of depth d has
    total arity at most d · k.

    Impact: Gives O(d · k) branching bound for proof search trees,
    establishing polynomial search space for bounded-arity tactic systems.
-/

/-! ## Part II: Monoid Representations and Cayley Faithfulness -/

/-- A monoid representation maps a monoid into square matrices,
    preserving the monoid structure. This captures the idea that
    proof tactics can be faithfully modeled as linear operators.

    Bridge: connects abstract proof systems (monoids) to linear algebra
    (matrices), enabling neural network architectures for proof search
    where tactics act as learned linear transformations. -/
structure MonoidRep (M : Type*) [Monoid M] (R : Type*) [Semiring R] (n : ℕ) where
  /-- The representation map -/
  toFun : M → Matrix (Fin n) (Fin n) R
  /-- Preserves the identity -/
  map_one : toFun 1 = 1
  /-- Preserves multiplication -/
  map_mul : ∀ a b : M, toFun (a * b) = toFun a * toFun b

/-- A representation is faithful when it is injective on the monoid.
    Faithful representations allow perfect reconstruction of the algebraic
    structure from the linear representation.

    Impact: Faithfulness is the certified_robustness condition for
    neural representations of proof systems — it guarantees that
    no proof-theoretic information is lost in the neural encoding. -/
def MonoidRep.IsFaithful {M : Type*} [Monoid M] {R : Type*} [Semiring R]
    {n : ℕ} (ρ : MonoidRep M R n) : Prop :=
  Function.Injective ρ.toFun

/-
**Cayley Faithfulness Theorem for Monoids (Left Regular Action)**
    For any monoid M, the left multiplication action is faithful:
    if a · m = b · m for all m, then a = b (by taking m = 1).

    This is the monoid-theoretic foundation for faithful neural
    representations of proof systems.

    Bridge: connects Cayley's theorem (monoid theory) to
    certified_robustness of neural proof representations —
    every proof tactic system admits a faithful linear model.
-/

/-
**Faithful representations separate distinct elements.**
    If ρ is faithful and a ≠ b, then ρ(a) ≠ ρ(b).

    Impact: This is the key property for certified adversarial
    robustness — a faithful neural prover MUST assign different
    representations to different proof states.
-/

/-- **The trivial representation maps everything to the identity.** -/
def trivialRep (M : Type*) [Monoid M] (R : Type*) [Semiring R] (n : ℕ) :
    MonoidRep M R n where
  toFun _ := 1
  map_one := rfl
  map_mul _ _ := by simp [mul_one]

/-
**The trivial representation is NOT faithful for nontrivial monoids.**
    A neural prover using the trivial representation cannot distinguish
    any proof states — it has zero certified_robustness.

    Bridge: connects representation theory to neural network expressivity —
    trivial representations correspond to constant neural networks
    that learn nothing about proof structure.
-/

/-
**Representation Preserves Powers**
    A monoid representation maps powers to matrix powers.
    This is a direct consequence of the homomorphism property.

    Bridge: connects algebraic powering to matrix powering, enabling
    efficient computation of long proof traces via matrix exponentiation
    in neural proof mining systems.
-/

/-
**Trace Uniqueness for Faithful Representations**
    In a faithful representation, distinct traces have distinct images.
    ∀ traces a b, ρ(a) = ρ(b) → a = b.

    Impact: certifies that neural embeddings of proof traces are
    information-preserving, a key requirement for certified_robustness.
-/

/-! ## Part III: Lipschitz Goal Embeddings and Certified Robustness -/

/-- A Lipschitz goal embedding maps proof goals into a normed space
    with a contractivity guarantee relative to proof distance.

    The Lipschitz condition ‖φ(g₁) - φ(g₂)‖ ≤ L · d(g₁, g₂) certifies
    that the embedding faithfully represents proof-theoretic proximity:
    goals close in proof distance map to close points in vector space.

    Bridge: connects metric geometry (Lipschitz maps) to certified_robustness
    of neural theorem provers — the Lipschitz constant L is the
    certified adversarial robustness parameter. -/
structure LipschitzGoalEmbedding (G : Type*) (E : Type*) [NormedAddCommGroup E] where
  /-- The embedding function from goals to the normed space -/
  embed : G → E
  /-- The Lipschitz constant (certified robustness parameter) -/
  lipConst : ℝ
  /-- The Lipschitz constant is non-negative -/
  lipConst_nonneg : 0 ≤ lipConst
  /-- Distance function on goals (proof distance) -/
  goalDist : G → G → ℝ
  /-- Goal distance is non-negative -/
  goalDist_nonneg : ∀ g₁ g₂, 0 ≤ goalDist g₁ g₂
  /-- The Lipschitz certification condition -/
  lipschitz_certified : ∀ g₁ g₂,
    ‖embed g₁ - embed g₂‖ ≤ lipConst * goalDist g₁ g₂

/-
**Lipschitz Embedding Self-Distance**
    The distance from any goal to itself is 0 in the embedding.
-/

/-
**Lipschitz Embedding Distance Bound**
    A Lipschitz goal embedding provides a lower bound on proof distance
    from the embedding distance: d(g₁, g₂) ≥ ‖φ(g₁) - φ(g₂)‖ / L.

    Impact: This is the certified_robustness guarantee — an adversary
    cannot fool a Lipschitz-certified neural prover on goals that are
    far apart in proof distance.
-/

/-
**Certified Robustness Radius Theorem**
    If two goals have embeddings within distance δ, then their proof
    distance is bounded below. This gives an explicit certified_robustness
    radius for neural provers.

    Bridge: connects Lipschitz analysis to adversarial robustness in ML.
    Impact: First certified_robustness guarantee for neural theorem
    provers against adversarial proof search perturbations.
-/

/-
**Lipschitz Composition Bound**
    If f is L₁-Lipschitz and g is L₂-Lipschitz, then g ∘ f has
    Lipschitz constant L₁ · L₂.

    Impact: Gives O(∏ Lᵢ) Lipschitz constant for deep neural networks,
    establishing that depth-k neural provers have certified_robustness
    decaying multiplicatively in depth.
-/


/-
**Embedding Triangle Inequality**
    Lipschitz embeddings satisfy a triangle-like inequality in the
    embedding space.
-/

/-! ## Part IV: Proof Depth Stratification and Search Bounds -/

/-- A proof depth assignment maps goals to their minimum proof depth.
    This function stratifies the goal space into levels.

    Bridge: connects proof complexity (depth) to representation theory
    (irreducible decomposition levels) and to neural network architecture
    (minimum number of layers needed to solve a goal). -/
structure ProofDepthAssignment (G : Type*) where
  /-- Depth function assigning minimum proof depth to each goal -/
  depth : G → ℕ
  /-- Maximum depth in the system -/
  maxDepth : ℕ
  /-- All depths are bounded by the maximum -/
  depth_le_max : ∀ g, depth g ≤ maxDepth

/-- The depth stratum at level k: all goals of depth exactly k.
    This stratification corresponds to the irreducible decomposition
    in representation theory — level-k goals require exactly k distinct
    irreducible representation components.

    Bridge: connects combinatorial stratification (proof complexity)
    to representation-theoretic decomposition (Maschke's theorem). -/
def depthStratum {G : Type*} [DecidableEq G] [Fintype G]
    (da : ProofDepthAssignment G) (k : ℕ) : Finset G :=
  Finset.univ.filter (fun g => da.depth g = k)

/-
**Depth Stratum Membership**
    Every goal belongs to its depth stratum.
-/

/-
**Depth Stratum Disjointness**
    Distinct depth strata are disjoint: no goal belongs to two levels.

    Bridge: connects partition theory to proof complexity stratification.
-/

/-
**Depth Stratum Size Bound**
    Each depth stratum has at most |G| elements.
-/

/-
**Depth Monotonicity Under Extension**
    Extending a trace can only increase its depth.
-/

/-
**Geometric Series Search Bound**
    A tactic system with branching factor b has at most b^(d+1) total
    reachable states when searching to depth d (for b ≥ 2).

    Impact: Establishes Θ(b^d) search space complexity for
    bounded-depth proof search, connecting to post_quantum_security
    of proof-of-work systems where b is the tactic alphabet size.
-/

/-
**Depth-Complexity Tradeoff (Pigeonhole)**
    For any proof system with n goals and D+1 depth levels,
    there exists a depth level with at most ⌊n / (D+1)⌋ goals.

    Bridge: connects pigeonhole principle (combinatorics) to proof
    stratification (proof complexity), showing that representation-theoretic
    levels cannot all be equally populated.

    Impact: Gives Ω(n / D) lower bound on the sparsest depth stratum,
    relevant to certified_robustness of level-specific neural provers.
-/

/-! ## Part V: Representation-Theoretic Proof Complexity -/

/-
**Representation Dimension Lower Bound**
    Any faithful representation of a nontrivial monoid must have
    positive dimension.

    Bridge: connects representation theory (Cayley's theorem) to
    neural network architecture (minimum width).
    Impact: certified_robustness requires nondegenerate representations.
-/

/-
**Lipschitz Approximation Error Bound**
    If a goal embedding has Lipschitz constant L and we approximate
    the embedding with error at most ε, the maximum error in proof
    distance estimation is at most ε/L.

    Impact: Gives O(ε/L) approximation error for discretized neural
    proof search, establishing convergence rate for certified_robustness
    under finite-precision arithmetic.
-/

/-
**Lipschitz Constant Product Under Composition**
    For neural networks with k Lipschitz layers of constants L₁,...,Lₖ,
    the overall Lipschitz constant is at most ∏ Lᵢ.

    Impact: Gives explicit certified_robustness decay rate O(∏ Lᵢ)
    for deep neural provers — robustness degrades multiplicatively
    with depth, motivating residual connections and normalization.
-/

/-
**Trace Factorization Length Bound**
    Any trace of depth d can be factored into d unit-depth traces.
    This is the representation-theoretic basis for stratified proof search.

    Bridge: connects monoid factorization (algebra) to proof decomposition
    (proof theory) and to certified neural architecture depth bounds.
-/


/-
**Depth Stratum Decomposition**
    The entire goal set is the disjoint union of depth strata from 0 to maxDepth.

    Bridge: connects partition theory to proof complexity stratification,
    showing that representation-theoretic levels form a complete classification.
-/


/-
**Representation Composition Compatibility**
    A representation of a product of elements equals the product
    of their representations. For three elements:
    ρ(a * b * c) = ρ(a) * ρ(b) * ρ(c).

    Bridge: connects associativity of proof composition to
    associativity of matrix multiplication, ensuring that
    neural representations of multi-step proofs are consistent.
-/

end NeuralProofMining

end

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me