A proof-kind receipt cannot claim the novelty axis
ProvedCouretOaiBridge01.StatusTransport.BridgeReceipts.proof_receipt_cannot_transport_noveltycouret-programmecouret-unification-20261108
A bridge receipt records source and target nodes, one of semantic/replay/novelty/justification axes, a dependency kind, nonempty bridge-statement/witness/version strings, reopened axes including its own axis, different source/target cases, and a true refined-policy permission. If a receipt has dependency kind proof, then its axis is not novelty.
The refined policy requires a novelty-kind dependency for novelty transport.
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_Couret_STAT_TRANS_08_BridgeReceipts_087a93e69025 import Mathlib.Data.Set.Basic import Definitions.Def_Couret_STAT_TRANS_07_ConcreteRegistry_d1fd54ec4183 import Definitions.Def_Couret_STAT_TRANS_07_RefinedPolicy_ed1e12af9529 /-! # STAT-TRANS-08 — Bridge receipts Cross-case transport is forbidden by default. An exceptional bridge is represented by an explicit receipt carrying source, target, axis, dependency kind, bridge statement, witness reference, version reference, and declared invalidation consequences. Lean verifies the receipt schema and the graph admission rule. A string reference to an external artifact is metadata, not authentication of that artifact. No RH claim. No novelty claim. -/ namespace CouretOaiBridge01 namespace StatusTransport namespace BridgeReceipts open ConcreteRegistry open RefinedPolicy
Formal statement
theorem proof_receipt_cannot_transport_novelty
(r : BridgeReceipt)
(hk : r.kind = DependencyKind.proof) :
r.axis ≠ StatusAxisV2.novelty := by sorry
end BridgeReceipts
end StatusTransport
end CouretOaiBridge01
Source
Alexandre Couret, https://github.com/alexcour/couret-finite-verifications/blob/d71ed2dafa9daa082f1a801b51d8a58abdb2c473/research/lean/CouretOaiBridge01/STAT_TRANS_08_BridgeReceipts.lean#L133-L143, lines 133–143; source file SHA-256 a2817030ed438a98e6bcab5eb9b3ab12126da52b32e8fe7707b8fcf1cc99482e; theorem CouretOaiBridge01.StatusTransport.BridgeReceipts.proof_receipt_cannot_transport_novelty