Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Waldschmidt 2005 (Variations), Cor. 2.13, corrected: if (Λᵢⱼ) ∈ ℒ̃²ˣ³, Λ₁₁, Λ₂₁ ∈ ℝ ∪ iℝ, and 1, Λ₁₁, Λ₂₁ and 1, Λ₂₁, Λ₂₂, Λ₂₃, Λ̄₂₂, Λ̄₂₃ are Q̄-free, then Λ₁₁Λ₂₂ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₂ or Λ₁₁Λ₂₃ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₃ ∉ ℒ̃

Proved
DiazModulus.variations_cor_2_13_corrected

by carlok · Nov 14, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

diaz-modulus-leannumber-theorytranscendence

Here Q‾\overline{\mathbb Q}Q​ is the field of algebraic numbers, L\mathcal LL the set of logarithms of algebraic numbers (z∈Cz \in \mathbb Cz∈C with eze^zez algebraic), and L~\widetilde{\mathcal L}L the Q‾\overline{\mathbb Q}Q​-vector space spanned by 111 and L\mathcal LL. A subspace S⊆CdS \subseteq \mathbb C^dS⊆Cd is rational if it is spanned by vectors with algebraic coordinates.

Let M=(Λij)M = (\Lambda_{ij})M=(Λij​) be a 2×32 \times 32×3 matrix with entries in L~\widetilde{\mathcal L}L. Assume that Λ11\Lambda_{11}Λ11​ and Λ21\Lambda_{21}Λ21​ are each real or purely imaginary (Λ11‾=±Λ11\overline{\Lambda_{11}} = \pm\Lambda_{11}Λ11​​=±Λ11​ and Λ21‾=±Λ21\overline{\Lambda_{21}} = \pm\Lambda_{21}Λ21​​=±Λ21​), that 1,Λ11,Λ211, \Lambda_{11}, \Lambda_{21}1,Λ11​,Λ21​ are linearly independent over Q‾\overline{\mathbb Q}Q​, and that the six numbers 1,Λ21,Λ22,Λ23,Λ22‾,Λ23‾1, \Lambda_{21}, \Lambda_{22}, \Lambda_{23}, \overline{\Lambda_{22}}, \overline{\Lambda_{23}}1,Λ21​,Λ22​,Λ23​,Λ22​​,Λ23​​ are linearly independent over Q‾\overline{\mathbb Q}Q​. Then at least one of

Λ11Λ22−Λ21Λ12,Λ11Λ23−Λ21Λ13\Lambda_{11}\Lambda_{22} - \Lambda_{21}\Lambda_{12}, \qquad \Lambda_{11}\Lambda_{23} - \Lambda_{21}\Lambda_{13}Λ11​Λ22​−Λ21​Λ12​,Λ11​Λ23​−Λ21​Λ13​

is not in L~\widetilde{\mathcal L}L.

Preamble
import Definitions.Def_DiazModulus
Formal statement
open Complex ComplexConjugate

namespace DiazModulus

theorem variations_cor_2_13_corrected (M : Matrix (Fin 2) (Fin 3) ℂ) (hM : ∀ i j, M i j ∈ LogAlgTilde)
    (h₁₁ : conj (M 0 0) = M 0 0 ∨ conj (M 0 0) = -M 0 0)
    (h₂₁ : conj (M 1 0) = M 1 0 ∨ conj (M 1 0) = -M 1 0)
    (h1 : LinearIndependent (↥Qbar) ![1, M 0 0, M 1 0])
    (h6 : LinearIndependent (↥Qbar) ![1, M 1 0, M 1 1, M 1 2, conj (M 1 1), conj (M 1 2)]) :
    M 0 0 * M 1 1 - M 1 0 * M 0 1 ∉ LogAlgTilde ∨ M 0 0 * M 1 2 - M 1 0 * M 0 2 ∉ LogAlgTilde := by
  sorry

end DiazModulus
Source
M. Waldschmidt, Variations on the six exponentials theorem, in Algebra and Number Theory (Hyderabad), Hindustan Book Agency, 2005, 338–355, Cor. 2.13 (p. 346; proof p. 347), with a corrected hypothesis. The printed Cor. 2.13 is false as stated: Λ₁₁ = 1, Λ₁₂ = Λ₁₃ = 0, Λ₂₁ = log 2, Λ₂₂ = Log(2 + i), Λ₂₃ = Log(3 + 2i) (principal logarithms) satisfy its hypotheses, the six numbers 1, log 2, Log(2 ± i), Log(3 ± 2i) being linearly independent over Q̄ by Baker's theorem, while Λ₁₁Λ₂₂ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₂ = Log(2 + i) and Λ₁₁Λ₂₃ − Λ₂₁Λ₁₃ = Log(3 + 2i) lie in ℒ. This node assumes instead that 1, Λ₁₁, Λ₂₁ are linearly independent over Q̄ (in place of 'Λ₂₁ ≠ 0 and Λ₁₁/Λ₂₁ transcendental'), as in M. Waldschmidt, The role of complex conjugation in transcendental number theory, 2005, Cor. 6.3; the printed hypothesis Λ₁₂, Λ₁₃ ∈ ℝ ∪ iℝ is not assumed. The printed proof applies Cor. 2.12 to the matrix with the conjugate columns (Λ̄₁ⱼ, Λ̄₂ⱼ), j = 2, 3; it needs signs on these columns when Λ₁₁ and Λ₂₁ are of different type (one real, the other purely imaginary). The proof here applies Role Cor. 6.3 to the columns (ε₂Λ̄₁ⱼ, ε₁Λ̄₂ⱼ), where Λ̄₁₁ = ε₁Λ₁₁ and Λ̄₂₁ = ε₂Λ₂₁ with ε₁, ε₂ ∈ {1, −1}. Formal proof: Diaz modulus mission, 14 November 2026 (C. Perassi).

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me