(12)–(13), p. 18 — the maximizers of y ↦ y(θ₁⁽ᵖ⁾+y)⁻ over y ≥ γ, corrected; their least element is max{γ, −½θ₁⁽ᵖ⁾}
ProvedCostlyShort.ShortMarket.eq12_eq13_cost_selectionLet be the market prices of risk of asset 1 for the optimist and the pessimist, and their wealths, and the lending yield per unit of volatility, with (condition (11)). Let
be the lending agent's revenue (10) and the set of with for all . Then
- if , and otherwise;
- the least element of is
Part 1 is (12): the optimist never shorts at a cost , so the revenue is the pessimist's alone; where she does not short at any admissible cost, the cost is undetermined. Part 2 is the selection (13) the paper makes from then on.
Formalization Note The page prints the undetermined case of (12) with the indicator . The correct condition is (that is, by (7)): for and the revenue vanishes on , so every is a maximizer while the printed formula gives . The least element (13) is the same in every case. The hypothesis holds in equilibrium by (14), and is (11).
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_CostlyShort_ShortMarket_Setting
namespace CostlyShort.ShortMarket
theorem eq12_eq13_cost_selection (θ₁o θ₁p Wo Wp γ : ℝ)
(hγ : 0 ≤ γ) (hWo : 0 ≤ Wo) (hWp : 0 < Wp) (h11 : 0 < θ₁o + γ) :
{y | γ ≤ y ∧ ∀ z, γ ≤ z → lendingRevenue θ₁o θ₁p Wo Wp z ≤ lendingRevenue θ₁o θ₁p Wo Wp y} =
(if 0 ≤ θ₁p + γ then Set.Ici γ else {max γ (-θ₁p / 2)}) ∧
IsLeast {y | γ ≤ y ∧ ∀ z, γ ≤ z →
lendingRevenue θ₁o θ₁p Wo Wp z ≤ lendingRevenue θ₁o θ₁p Wo Wp y} (max γ (-θ₁p / 2)) := by sorry
end CostlyShort.ShortMarket
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.