Subgroup obstruction to Cayley isomorphism
ProvedCouret.CayleyDoublet.abelianNoIso_of_doublet_mem_closurecouret-programmecouret-unification-20261108
Let be an abelian group. For , assume , , , , and . There is no bijection preserving all directed Cayley arcs between supports and .
No finiteness hypothesis is imposed.
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_Couret_CayleyTwoColourAbelian_32e780a833c0
import Mathlib
import Theorems.Thm_Couret_CayleyDoublet_halfTurn_isMate
import Theorems.Thm_Couret_CayleyDoublet_halfTurn_unique_of_order_three
import Theorems.Thm_Couret_CayleyDoublet_singleton_step_preserved
import Theorems.Thm_Couret_CayleyDoublet_tripleArc_iff
import Theorems.Thm_Couret_CayleyDoublet_uniqueMate_natural
import Definitions.Def_Couret_CayleyDoubletCore_59125eeb43b1
import Definitions.Def_Couret_CayleyDoubletCore_59125eeb43b1
set_option autoImplicit false
/-!
COU-20 — abelian two-colour bridge (17 Oct 2026).
The directed isomorphism dichotomy for the exceptional triple pair is
assembled below, including its exact order-three quotient formulation.
It retains a nonzero half-turn and generation by a,d,h; no finiteness or
cyclicity assumption is added. No spectral-necessity or undirected-graph
extension, independent human review, release or priority claim.
-/
namespace Couret.CayleyDoublet
section AbelianTwoColour
variable {G : Type*} [AddCommGroup G] [DecidableEq G]
/-!
COU-20: ordered-square algebra ported from the STROBO proof (PR #25,
Strobo2TorsCore.lean at d4a1f9718). This internal dependency is intentionally
copied with provenance rather than merging separate research branches.
-/
/-!
COU-20: a CONDITIONAL construction of the d -> -d reflection.
This section first treats a supplied 3-torsion idempotent projection.
The final normal-form construction below derives it from generation by
a,d,h and properness of the subgroup generated by a,h.
-/
/-!
## COU-20: Three-valued quotient character as a constructive intermediary
If the index-three quotient provides a character χ : G →+ ZMod 3 with
χ(a)=χ(h)=0 and χ(d)=1, the required additive projection can be
constructed explicitly. The final elementary normal-form theorem below
derives χ from the stated generation and subgroup properness hypotheses.
-/
/-!
## COU-20: closure-level intrinsic obstruction (no cyclicity hypothesis)
This strengthens the previous "b = k•a modulo h" obstruction:
an isomorphism preserves shifts by both a and h, hence by the subgroup
they generate. No cardinality bound and no finite-group assumption.
-/
Formal statement
theorem abelianNoIso_of_doublet_mem_closure
(a b c h : G)
(hhalf : h + h = 0) (hne : h ≠ 0)
(hab : a ≠ b) (habh : a ≠ b + h)
(hac : a ≠ c) (hach : a ≠ c + h)
(hthreeT : (a - c) + (a - c) + (a - c) = 0 ∨
(a - c) + (a - c) + (a - c) = h)
(hbK : b ∈ AddSubgroup.closure ({a, h} : Set G))
(hbc : b ≠ c) (hbch : b ≠ c + h)
(f : G ≃ G)
(hf : ∀ x y, CayleyArc (TripleSupport a b h) x y ↔
CayleyArc (TripleSupport a c h) (f x) (f y)) : False := by sorry
/-!
COU-20: formal assembly of the two directions.
The separated-support version exposes the exact hypotheses required
by the intrinsic-colour obstruction. The next corollary discharges
these separations from the order-three quotient arithmetic.
-/
/-!
## COU-20: exact separation criterion and order-three quotient corollary
-/
end AbelianTwoColour
end Couret.CayleyDoublet
Source
Alexandre Couret, https://github.com/alexcour/couret-finite-verifications/blob/65b828d9ffd016ce2a1b05403f303fa5f948c10f/research/correspondants_20261013/lean/CayleyTwoColourAbelian.lean#L751-L811, lines 751–811; source file SHA-256 c9643d6e3a677d5a903623825d50a309d87175a21ace2b7ab56939d9189f13b1; theorem Couret.CayleyDoublet.abelianNoIso_of_doublet_mem_closure