Theorem 2, p. 13 — a free experience of quality u^x ≤ û^x raises both optimal profit and consumer welfare
ProvedExpRetail.Monopoly.theorem_2Consider the monopoly model of §3.1 under the standing assumptions , , , , with and arbitrary. Let , be the profit (4) and the log-sum consumer welfare with a free experience of quality , and , the profit (5) and the consumer welfare without one. Then:
- Low quality is win-win. A no-experience optimal price exists, and there is a threshold such that for every quality an optimal price exists and, for every such and every ,
- Otherwise the retailer can be worse off. There is a quality at which an optimal price exists and, for every such and every ,
This is the paper's Theorem 2: "there exists a threshold such that offering an experience with utility improves both the retailer's profit and consumer welfare. Otherwise, an experiential offering can make the retailer and/or consumers worse off."
Formalization Note "Improves" is read as a strict improvement over the no-experience optimum, with welfare evaluated at the optimal prices. Existence of optimal prices is asserted, not assumed; uniqueness is not claimed. Consumer welfare is the logit log-sum (the paper does not define it; this convention reproduces Figure 1(d)). The informal second sentence is formalized as its retailer half: for every admissible parameter set some quality hurts the retailer at every optimal price. The theorem does not claim that every hurts someone, and neither does the paper.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ExpRetail_Monopoly_Model
namespace ExpRetail.Monopoly
theorem theorem_2 (P : Params) (hP : P.Standing) :
((∃ pN : ℝ, IsOptPriceN P pN) ∧
∃ uhat : ℝ, 0 < uhat ∧ ∀ ux : ℝ, 0 ≤ ux → ux ≤ uhat →
(∃ p : ℝ, IsOptPrice P ux p) ∧
∀ p pN : ℝ, IsOptPrice P ux p → IsOptPriceN P pN →
profitN P pN < profit P ux p ∧ CSN P pN < CS P ux p) ∧
(∃ ux : ℝ, 0 ≤ ux ∧ (∃ p : ℝ, IsOptPrice P ux p) ∧
∀ p pN : ℝ, IsOptPrice P ux p → IsOptPriceN P pN →
profit P ux p < profitN P pN) := by sorry
end ExpRetail.Monopoly
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.