The critical line theorem.
ProvedBerggrenZeta.silver_denom_eq_zero_iffaether-catalognovelty
The critical line theorem. The poles of the silver Ihara zeta of the Berggren tree
are exactly the points whose real part is the silver abscissa
σ₀ = log 3 / (2 log(1+√2)) and whose imaginary part is an integer multiple of
π / log(1+√2). In particular every pole lies on the single vertical line Re s = σ₀:
an exactly solvable analogue of the Riemann Hypothesis for the Berggren tree.
theorem BerggrenZeta.silver_denom_eq_zero_iff(s : ℂ) :
1 - 3 * (silverUnit : ℂ) ^ (-2 * s) = 0 ↔
s.re = silverAbscissa ∧ ∃ k : ℤ, s.im = k * Real.pi / Real.log silverUnit := by sorry
Formalization Note Transplanted verbatim from the Aether Catalog source Novelty/BerggrenTreeCriticalLine.lean; the statement is byte-identical to the source declaration, elaborated with autoImplicit disabled in the platform environment.
Preamble
-- Thm stub generated from Novelty/BerggrenTreeCriticalLine.lean
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_BerggrenTreeCriticalLine
import Definitions.Def_Novelty_BerggrenTreeSilverGrowth
/-!
# A provable critical line: the silver Ihara zeta of the Berggren tree
The Berggren tree is a regular ternary tree whose extremal (Pell) branch grows at the rate
`ε² = 3 + 2√2`, where `ε = 1 + √2` is the fundamental unit of `ℤ[√2]` and the eigenvalue of
the hyperbolic Berggren generator (`Novelty.BerggrenTreeSilverGrowth`). Weighting each of
the `3^k` nodes at depth `k` by the *silver length* `ε^{2k}` instead of by its actual
hypotenuse gives the **silver Ihara-type zeta function** of the tree,
`Z_ε(s) = ∑_{k ≥ 0} 3^k ε^{-2ks} = (1 - 3 ε^{-2s})⁻¹`.
Unlike the true tree zeta (whose abscissa is `1`, see `Novelty.BerggrenTreeZetaAbscissa`),
this object is *exactly solvable*: it is a rational function of `ε^{-2s}`, hence
meromorphic on all of `ℂ`, and its poles can be computed in closed form. The result is a
rigorous analogue of the Riemann Hypothesis for the Berggren tree:
> **All poles of `Z_ε` lie on the single vertical line `Re s = σ₀`, where
> `σ₀ = log 3 / (2 log(1+√2))`, and on that line they form the arithmetic progression
> `s = σ₀ + i k π / log(1+√2)`, `k ∈ ℤ`.**
The "critical line" is therefore determined by exactly two pieces of tree geometry: the
branching number `3` and the silver growth exponent `2 log ε`; the spacing of the poles is
the reciprocal silver length `π / log ε`, the analogue of the Ihara/Selberg spectral gap.
## Main results
* `silverZeta_eq_tsum` — the Dirichlet series `∑ 3^k ε^{-2ks}` converges exactly on the
half-plane `Re s > σ₀` and sums to `Z_ε`;
* `silver_denom_eq_zero_iff` — **the critical line theorem**: the pole set of `Z_ε` is
`{s : Re s = σ₀, Im s ∈ (π / log ε) ℤ}`;
* `silverZeta_analyticAt` and `silverZeta_meromorphicOn` — meromorphic continuation to `ℂ`;
* `silverAbscissa_lt_one` — the silver critical abscissa is strictly smaller than the true
abscissa `1` of the tree zeta function: the silver model *underestimates* the density of
small hypotenuses, which is the precise reason the moonshot conjecture fails.
-/
open BerggrenZeta
open Real Complex
/-! ## Part A. The half-plane of convergence -/
/-! ## Part B. The critical line -/Formal statement
theorem BerggrenZeta.silver_denom_eq_zero_iff(s : ℂ) :
1 - 3 * (silverUnit : ℂ) ^ (-2 * s) = 0 ↔
s.re = silverAbscissa ∧ ∃ k : ℤ, s.im = k * Real.pi / Real.log silverUnit := by sorrySource