Realized has no removable novel
ProvedAPFB05.realized_has_no_removable_novelapfapf-referencesib-v44-2026-11
Under guarded B05, suppose actual minimizes familyCost over a supplied family set containing S. If d is tested and support-novel over S and both S and insert d S are ledger-admissible, then actual is not insert d S. This uses the explicitly supplied family minimum, not a certified physical A2 binding.
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_APF_B05_DeclaredInput_r2
import Mathlib.Tactic.Linarith
set_option autoImplicit false
open APFPaper1.Source
variable {Context : Type*} {D P R Record : Context → Type*} [∀ g, DecidableEq (D g)]
(wholeResource : (g : Context) → P g → R g)
(calibration : (g : Context) → R g → NNReal)
(maintained : (g : Context) → P g → Set (Record g))
(sufficient : (g : Context) → P g → Set (Record g) → D g → Prop)
(usesToRealize : (g : Context) → P g → D g → Set (Record g) → Prop)
(tested : (g : Context) → D g → Prop)
(C epsilon : Context → ℝ)
Formal statement
theorem APFB05.realized_has_no_removable_novel
(hB05 : APFB05.MarginalFloor wholeResource calibration maintained sufficient usesToRealize
tested C epsilon)
(g : Context) (families : Set (Finset (D g))) (actual : Finset (D g))
(hA2 : actual ∈ families ∧ ∀ a ∈ families,
familyCost (wholeResource g) (calibration g) (maintained g) (sufficient g) (usesToRealize g)
actual ≤
familyCost (wholeResource g) (calibration g) (maintained g) (sufficient g) (usesToRealize g) a)
(S : Finset (D g)) (d : D g) (hSmem : S ∈ families) (htested : tested g d)
(hS : familyAdmissible (wholeResource g) (calibration g) (maintained g)
(sufficient g) (usesToRealize g) (C g) S)
(hSd : familyAdmissible (wholeResource g) (calibration g) (maintained g)
(sufficient g) (usesToRealize g) (C g) (insert d S))
(hnew : supportNovel (wholeResource g) (calibration g) (maintained g)
(sufficient g) (usesToRealize g) S d) :
actual ≠ insert d S := by sorry
Source
Sib v44 Theorems/Thm_APFB05_A2_economy.lean:54
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).