Finite theta system with norm relations and critical-value zero set (inverse-seed convention)
ProvedHorizontalPadicL.seededFiniteThetaSystem_exists_with_normRelations_and_criticalZeroSet_inverseSeeddirichlet-charactersnumber-theoryp-adic-l-functions
For an odd prime and a faithful horizontal-character realization, the scaled algebraic modular symbols define one finite theta system that simultaneously satisfies the Hecke norm relations and the finite-level Birch--Stevens zero-set formula. Thus the theta family cannot be chosen independently of the critical L-values.
This replacement uses the inverse-seed convention matching MTT criticalLValue: the orderly-prime expression and Euler augmentation are eta(l)*a_l - eta(l)^2 - epsilon(l). The critical values and seed hypotheses themselves retain the character eta. It supersedes HorizontalPadicL.seededFiniteThetaSystem_exists_with_normRelations_and_criticalZeroSet.
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_KN_SeededFiniteThetaCriticalZeroSet import Theorems.Thm_MTT_birch_mellin_formula import Definitions.Def_KN_InverseSeedConvention set_option autoImplicit false noncomputable section
Formal statement
namespace HorizontalPadicL
/-- The faithfully pushed-forward theta elements constructed from the scaled
algebraic modular symbols simultaneously satisfy their Hecke norm relations
and the finite-level Birch--Stevens zero-set formula. Keeping both properties
on the same witness rules out spurious systems such as the identically-zero
theta family. -/
theorem seededFiniteThetaSystem_exists_with_normRelations_and_criticalZeroSet_inverseSeed
{N k p B : ℕ} {ι : MTT.Qbar →+* ℂ} [Fact p.Prime]
(hN : 0 < N) (hk : 2 ≤ k) (heven : Even k)
(f : MTT.Eigenform N k ι) (hnew : IsNewEigenform f)
(P : MTT.Periods k ι f.form) (η : DirichletCharacterWithLevel)
(hηprim : η.2.IsPrimitive) (hηeven : η.2 (-1) = 1)
(ιp : MTT.Qbar →+* ℂ_[p]) (hpodd : p ≠ 2)
(L : SeededHorizontalPrimeDataV3 p ιp f η B)
(characters : SeededHorizontalCharacterRealizationV3 L)
(hcharacters : characters.HasExpectedProperties)
(scale : IntegralPeriodScale f ιp P)
(hcomparison : ∀ s j a m, j ≤ k - 2 → m ≠ 0 →
ι (MTT.algebraicSymbol P s j a m) * P.omega s =
signedModularSymbol f.form s j a m) :
∃ Θ : SeededFiniteThetaDataV3 L,
Θ.characters = characters ∧
Θ.SatisfiesNormRelations ∧
Θ.HasSeededCriticalZeroSet := by
sorry
end HorizontalPadicLSource
Kriz--Nordentoft, Horizontal p-adic L-functions, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20678, Sections 3.3 and 5.1, especially Corollary 3.6, Corollary 5.2 and Corollary 5.4.