A pendulum with just enough energy to go vertical never gets there
ProvedPendulum.never_reaches_verticalA pendulum with exactly the energy needed to stand upright never reaches the vertical.
Let and let be a motion of the pendulum lying on the separatrix, that is, whose energy equals the energy of the upright position: at every time
equivalently . If at the initial time the bob is strictly below the vertical, , then
This is the dynamical counterpart of the divergence of the period integral as noted in the article: the motion approaches the upright position asymptotically, in both time directions, but attains it at no finite time — "a pendulum with just the right energy to go vertical will never actually get there". Conversely, a pendulum released just short of the vertical can take an arbitrarily long time to fall.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_PendulumDefs
namespace Pendulum
theorem never_reaches_vertical (g l : ℝ) (hg : 0 < g) (hl : 0 < l)
(theta omega alpha : ℝ → ℝ) (h : IsMotion g l theta omega alpha)
(hsep : ∀ t, omega t ^ 2 = 2 * (g / l) * (1 + Real.cos (theta t)))
(hinit : |theta 0| < Real.pi) :
∀ t, |theta t| < Real.pi := by sorry
end PendulumRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · non-blind: written by the drafting agent (Aristotle by Harmonic)
Non-blind read-back — not independent testimony. This read-back was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statement it describes, at the explicit instruction of the proposal's owner. It was not produced by an independent auditor reading the code blind, so it is not independent evidence that the formalization is faithful: an author who knows what the code is meant to say tends to read that meaning into it. Please audit the statement against the source directly, and treat this text only as a convenience rendering.
Two real numbers are given with and , together with functions . The hypotheses are:
-
the triple is a motion for these parameters: everywhere , , and ;
-
for every real ,
- .
The conclusion is that for every real , .
Two features of the hypotheses are worth making explicit. Hypothesis 2 is imposed at every time, not only at time ; it selects the motions whose energy is exactly the critical one. The hypotheses are satisfiable — for instance by the motion with and — so the claim is not vacuous; they also admit the constant solution only if vanishes identically, which contradicts hypothesis 2, so the constant zero motion is excluded. The conclusion is a strict inequality at every real time, in both time directions, and says nothing about the limiting behaviour as .