Lifting is defeasible
ProvedTranscendenceTower.Lifting.lift_defeasibleformalizing-contextlogicnonmonotonic-logic
Lifting is genuinely defeasible: a target that contradicts the source forces an assertion to be declared abnormal, and the fact that would otherwise have transferred is then unavailable.
Concretely, let the source assert and the target assert . Three things hold together:
- blocking nothing is inadmissible — the lifted context asserts both and and has no model;
- blocking is admissible;
- in the resulting lifted context, is no longer a consequence.
Each part is needed. Without the first, nothing would compel a blocking set to be non-empty. Without the second, the conflict might have been unresolvable rather than merely costly. Without the third, one could object that the blocking was cosmetic and the fact survived anyway.
This is the behaviour specializes is designed to have: transfer is the default, and a conflict in the target defeats it rather than producing an inconsistency.
Preamble
import Definitions.Def_TranscendenceTowerLiftConflicts set_option autoImplicit false open TranscendenceTower TranscendenceTower.ContextTheories
Formal statement
namespace TranscendenceTower.Lifting
theorem lift_defeasible :
¬ Admissible srcP tgtNotP ∅
∧ Admissible srcP tgtNotP {pA}
∧ pA ∉ Cn (Lift srcP tgtNotP {pA}) := by sorry
end TranscendenceTower.Lifting
Source
Mateo Estrada, Harmless and Pointless: Consistency, rigidity, and the indeterminacy of context transfer in McCarthy's formalization of context, 7 September 2026, Section 7, defeasibility of lifting (not numbered in the paper). Lifting after John McCarthy, Notes on Formalizing Context, 1993, Section 4.