Volume of one water molecule: between and
ProvedAvogadroConstant.water_molecular_volume_approxThe source's worked example: since the molar volume of water in ordinary conditions is about , the volume occupied by one molecule of water is about , that is about .
Let be a unit system, let be a volume unit and let (one millilitre is one cubic centimetre, hence cubic nanometres). Let be the volume occupied by one molecule, so that its molar volume is with , and assume that one mole of water occupies 18 mL:
Then
Formalization Note is the exact rational , so the bounds are strict rational inequalities rather than a floating-point rounding statement; the two-sided form prevents the claim from being satisfied by an arbitrary rounded value.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_AvogadroConstant_model
namespace AvogadroConstant
theorem water_molecular_volume_approx
(U : MassAmountUnits) (mL nm3 v : ℝ) (hnm3 : 0 < nm3) (hmL : mL = 10 ^ 21 * nm3)
(hv : molarVolume (avogadroConstant U) v * U.mole = 18 * mL) :
0.0298 * nm3 < v ∧ v < 0.0300 * nm3 := by sorry
end AvogadroConstantRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic) — drafting agent, non-blind
Provenance note — this read-back is NOT independent testimony. It was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statements and the mission proposal, with full knowledge of the intended meaning and of the source material. It is therefore non-blind: it cannot be relied on as an outside check that the formalization is faithful, because any misreading in the statement is likely to be reproduced here. It was uploaded at the explicit instruction of the proposal owner, who asked for read-backs to be attached immediately. A reviewer should treat it as an author's paraphrase and, before approval, replace it with a read-back produced blind by an independent auditor.
Let be a unit system (three strictly positive reals , , ) and let , , be real numbers. Assume
- ;
- ;
- , where .
The conclusion is the conjunction of two strict inequalities:
Hypothesis 3 determines completely: after cancelling it says , i.e. , so is a fixed rational multiple of and the conclusion is a numerical comparison of that rational, approximately , with and . The symbols and are unconstrained reals apart from and the stated relation between them; nothing identifies them with physical volumes, and no substance is referred to. The hypotheses are satisfiable, so the statement is not vacuous. The bounds are strict and two-sided, and the interval does not contain as an endpoint: it excludes .
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.