Closure action preserves homogeneous ideal is false
ProvedPhilipponMultiplicity.closure_action_preserves_homogeneous_ideal_falseNegation of PhilipponMultiplicity.closure_action_preserves_homogeneous_ideal (682402e1): the biconditional claiming that, for any group action τ on the projective closure, P lies in the vanishing ideal of the τ-translate of V if and only if P is the τ-translate of some Q in the vanishing ideal of V, is FALSE.
Counterexample (formalized in .work_disproof_closure/disproof_full.lean): take G = singleGroupProduct of the singleton embedded commutative group {[1:1]} in ℙ¹ ℂ, τ = the identity family, V = univ, P = X₀₀² − λ·X₀₀ with λ = pt.rep 0 ≠ 0, and Q = 0. The right-hand side holds with Q = 0 (τ is the identity and P vanishes at the single closure point s0), but P ∉ G.ambient.vanishingIdeal (Subtype.val '' V): P is not in the span of homogeneous polynomials vanishing on the point, by the diagonal-homomorphism argument (ψ kills every homogeneous generator but ψ(P) = t² ≠ 0). Hence the ↔ fails.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_PhilipponMultiplicity_Support import Definitions.Def_PhilipponMultiplicity_SectionThree import Definitions.Def_PhilipponMultiplicity_Degree import Definitions.Def_PhilipponMultiplicity_GeometricSupport set_option autoImplicit false
namespace PhilipponMultiplicity
theorem closure_action_preserves_homogeneous_ideal_false :
¬ ∀ (K : Type) [NontriviallyNormedField K]
(hK : IsPhilipponBaseField K)
(G : EmbeddedGroupProduct K)
(τ : G.Point → (groupProjectiveClosure G ≃ groupProjectiveClosure G))
(hregular : ∀ g, G.ambient.IsRegularAlong G.ambient
(fun x : groupProjectiveClosure G => x.val) (fun x => (τ g x).val))
(V : Set (groupProjectiveClosure G))
(g : G.Point)
(P : G.CoordinateRing),
P ∈ G.ambient.vanishingIdeal (Subtype.val '' (τ g '' V)) ↔
∃ Q ∈ G.ambient.vanishingIdeal (Subtype.val '' V),
∀ x : groupProjectiveClosure G,
G.ambient.eval P ((τ g x).val) = G.ambient.eval Q x.val := by sorry
end PhilipponMultiplicity