The five exponentials theorem: for ℚ-independent x₀, x₁ and y₀, y₁ and algebraic η ≠ 0, one of the e^{xᵢyⱼ} and e^{ηx₁/x₀} is transcendental
ProvedDiazModulus.five_exponentialsThe five exponentials theorem.
Let be linearly independent over , let be linearly independent over , and let be a non-zero algebraic number. Then at least one of the five numbers
is transcendental. ( by independence, so the quotient is defined.)
The sources number from : the fifth number is in Waldschmidt (1988, Cor. 2.2) and in DALAG (§11.3.3, Example 1), the same statement after exchanging and . Here is the set of logarithms of algebraic numbers (the with algebraic), and is the -vector space spanned by and , with the field of algebraic numbers.
Proof. Suppose the five numbers are algebraic, and put . (1) is linearly independent over : and are logarithms of algebraic numbers, linearly independent over since ; a relation with gives , and Baker's theorem (Schanuel.baker_linear_forms_in_logarithms, with no constant term) gives . (2) is linearly independent over : a relation , multiplied by , reads , where are -independent logarithms; Baker's theorem with the constant term gives , as . (3) The six products lie in : four are logarithms by hypothesis, , and is a logarithm by hypothesis. Roy's strong six exponentials theorem (DiazModulus.strong_six_exponentials_unconditional) says that (1)–(3) cannot hold together. This is the derivation of DALAG's Remark after Cor. 11.16 (p. 399): Baker's theorem turns -linear independence into -linear independence.
Novelty. None: this is the five exponentials theorem of Waldschmidt (1988, Cor. 2.2, p. 378), also DALAG §11.3.3, Example 1, p. 385. The derivation from Roy's strong six exponentials theorem (Roy 1992, Cor. 2; DALAG Cor. 11.16) and Baker's theorem is DALAG's Remark after Cor. 11.16, p. 399. The contribution of this node is the formal proof.
import Definitions.Def_DiazModulus
open Complex ComplexConjugate
namespace DiazModulus
/-- **The five exponentials theorem** (M. Waldschmidt, *On the transcendence methods of Gel'fond
and Schneider in several variables*, New Advances in Transcendence Theory (Durham 1986), 1988,
Cor. 2.2, p. 378; DALAG § 11.3.3, Example 1, p. 385).
Let `x₁, x₂` be `ℚ`-linearly independent, `y₁, y₂` be `ℚ`-linearly independent, and `η` a nonzero
algebraic number. Then at least one of the five numbers
`e^{x₁y₁}, e^{x₁y₂}, e^{x₂y₁}, e^{x₂y₂}, e^{η x₂ / x₁}` is transcendental.
(`x₁ ≠ 0` follows from the independence of `x`, so the quotient is well defined.) -/
theorem five_exponentials :
∀ x y : Fin 2 → ℂ, ∀ η : ℂ, LinearIndependent ℚ x → LinearIndependent ℚ y →
IsAlgebraic ℚ η → η ≠ 0 →
¬ ((∀ i j, IsAlgebraic ℚ (Complex.exp (x i * y j))) ∧
IsAlgebraic ℚ (Complex.exp (η * x 1 / x 0))) := by
sorry
end DiazModulus