Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Properness of `S4.2`.

Proved
MultiverseModalForcing.B_fails

by raver1975 · Sep 11, 2026 · Mathlib c5ea003 (Lean v4.30.0)

aether-catalogapplications

Properness of S4.2. The S5 axiom B : p → □◇p fails in the (reflexive, transitive, directed) sink forcing frame: the atom is true at wT, yet from the accessible sink world wF no forcing extension recovers its truth. Hence forcing does not validate S5.

theorem MultiverseModalForcing.B_fails:
    ¬ MValid sinkFrame.R sinkFrame.M
        (.imp (.atom true) (.box (MSentence.dia (.atom true)))) := by sorry

Formalization Note Transplanted verbatim from the Aether Catalog source Applications/MultiverseModalForcing.lean; the statement is byte-identical to the source declaration, elaborated with autoImplicit disabled in the platform environment.

Preamble
-- Thm stub generated from Applications/ProofTheoryAndLogic/MultiverseModalForcing.lean
import Mathlib
import Definitions.Def_Applications_ProofTheoryAndLogic_MultiverseModalForcing
/-
# The Modal Logic of Forcing — a Kripke-semantic deepening of Multiverse Set Theory

This file equips the combinatorial core of the set-theoretic *multiverse* with a
**modal structure of forcing**, following the Hamkins–Löwe programme:

* **possibility** `◇p` — `p` holds in *some* forcing (generic) extension;
* **necessity**  `□p` — `p` holds in *every* forcing extension.

Forcing extensions form a Kripke *frame*: an accessibility relation `R` on worlds
(models of set theory).  We give the standard Kripke semantics for a language of
modal set-theoretic sentences and prove that the forcing frame is **sound for the
modal system `S4.2`**, the theorem at the heart of the modal logic of forcing:

* `sound_K`      — the distribution axiom `□(p → q) → (□p → □q)` (any frame);
* `sound_Nec`    — the necessitation rule (any frame);
* `sound_T`      — `□p → p` from **reflexivity** of forcing (you force over yourself);
* `sound_Four`   — `□p → □□p` from **transitivity** (iterated forcing);
* `sound_Two`    — `◇□p → □◇p` from **directedness** (any two extensions have a
  common further extension — the amalgamation/product-forcing property).

Together `K, T, 4, .2` axiomatise `S4.2`.  We also prove the **duality**
`◇p ↔ ¬□¬p`, monotonicity and distribution laws, package the result as
`forcing_sound_S42`, instantiate the abstract frame with a concrete
*flip-reachability* forcing frame over the multiverse, and finally show the logic
is **properly weaker than `S5`**: the characteristic axiom `B : p → □◇p` **fails**
in a directed reflexive-transitive forcing frame (`B_fails`).  Thus forcing is
genuinely `S4.2` and not `S5` — you cannot, in general, force your way back.

Everything is proved from first principles over `Mathlib`, self-contained.
-/

open MultiverseModalForcing

open Classical

/-! ## Worlds and modal sentences -/




open MSentence



/-! ## Kripke semantics for forcing

`R w v` reads "`v` is a forcing extension of `w`".  `M` is the multiverse of
admissible worlds.  `meval R M w p` is the truth of `p` at world `w`. -/









/-! ## Duality between necessity and possibility -/



/-! ## Soundness of the modal system S4.2 for forcing frames

We isolate the three frame conditions that forcing satisfies and show each
validates the corresponding modal axiom. -/









/-! ## Derived modal principles -/






/-! ## Packaging the S4.2 soundness theorem -/



/-! ## A concrete forcing frame: flip-reachability

We model a generic extension deciding an atom the other way by *flipping* its
truth value.  Two worlds are mutually accessible when they differ on only
finitely many atoms — the reachable class under finitely many forcing steps. -/







/-! ## Properness: forcing is `S4.2`, not `S5`

The characteristic `S5` axiom `B : p → □◇p` fails in a directed reflexive
transitive forcing frame.  Hence the modal logic of forcing is *properly* weaker
than `S5`: from a generic extension you cannot in general force *back* to the
ground model. -/
Formal statement
theorem MultiverseModalForcing.B_fails:
    ¬ MValid sinkFrame.R sinkFrame.M
        (.imp (.atom true) (.box (MSentence.dia (.atom true)))) := by sorry
Source
https://github.com/paulklemstine/Lean/blob/53c2925a02/Catalog/Applications/MultiverseModalForcing.lean#L366

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me