Proposition 1 — sufficient conditions for the four optimal sourcing strategies
ProvedRespSourcing.Transparent.proposition1_optimal_strategyLet be baseline valuation, the responsible-sourcing premium, the socially conscious fraction, its fraction that exits following a violation, the violation probability, and the responsible and risky marginal costs, and the fixed violation penalty. Assume and . Set and . A strategy is optimal when its Table 2 profit is at least every one of the four profits.
Proposition 1 gives four sufficient conditions:
- Low-cost sourcing is optimal when
- Dual sourcing is optimal when
- Responsible niche sourcing is optimal when , neither low-cost nor dual sourcing is optimal, and
- Responsible mass market sourcing is optimal when , neither low-cost nor dual sourcing is optimal, and
This proposition identifies when each supplier configuration maximizes expected profit among the four strategies.
Formalization Note Part (ii) preserves the printed ; the appendix's pairwise dual-sourcing comparisons contain in that position. The printed hypothesis is stronger under the standing ranges. Parts (iii) and (iv) explicitly require so their quotient is defined.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_RespSourcing_Transparent_Model
namespace RespSourcing.Transparent
/-- Proposition 1, p. 2729, all four sufficient conditions, with part (ii) as printed. -/
theorem proposition1_optimal_strategy (p : Params) (hp : p.Standing) :
(p.r < p.Δ →
p.φ * (p.α * p.θ * (p.v - p.cNR) + p.cVP) <
p.Δ - max (p.θ * p.r - (1 - p.θ) * (p.v - p.cR)) 0 →
IsOptimal p .LC) ∧
(p.Δ < p.r →
p.φ * (p.α * p.θ * (p.v + p.r - p.cNR) + p.cVP) <
p.Δ * (1 - p.θ) + p.θ * p.r -
max (p.θ * p.r - (1 - p.θ) * (p.v - p.cR)) 0 →
IsOptimal p .DS) ∧
(0 < p.θ →
(p.v - p.cR) * (1 - p.θ) / p.θ < p.r →
¬ IsOptimal p .LC → ¬ IsOptimal p .DS → IsOptimal p .RN) ∧
(0 < p.θ →
p.r < (p.v - p.cR) * (1 - p.θ) / p.θ →
¬ IsOptimal p .LC → ¬ IsOptimal p .DS → IsOptimal p .RM) := by sorry
end RespSourcing.Transparent
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.