Observation 6 — Downward visibility suffices
DisprovedBonnetTerrain.NPC.observation_6For every orthogonal terrain and every guarding set of its listed vertices, the same set still guards every real point of the terrain when a guard may only see targets at its own height or below. This retains the printed assertion; the source counterexample is recorded separately in INSIGHTS.yaml.
Differences from the source:
- encoding: an orthogonal terrain and a guarding set at listed vertices → a nonempty indexed real simple polygonal chain satisfying orthogonality, with a finite set of vertex indices and non-strict boundary visibility; reason: represents the discrete guarding convention and all real target points, including vertical sides and straight-through subdivisions
import Definitions.Def_BonnetTerrain_NPC_Geometry
namespace BonnetTerrain.NPC
theorem observation_6
(T : BonnetTerrain.NPC.Chain) (hT : T.IsTerrain) (hO : T.IsOrthogonal)
(S : Finset (Fin (T.edgeCount + 1))) (hS : T.Guards S) :
T.GuardsDownward S := by sorry
end BonnetTerrain.NPC
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5
Setting. Let be a chain with edge count and vertices . Edge , for , is the closed segment
The carrier is the union of all vertices and all edges. The region above is
For points , " sees and " means that , , and the closed segment is contained in .
Hypotheses. Assume:
- is a terrain. Its vertices are pairwise distinct, is nondecreasing in , and whenever edges and with share a point , then and .
- is orthogonal. Every edge satisfies or .
- guards . is a finite set of vertex indices in , and every is seen together with for some .
Conclusion. Then guards downward:
The guard index in the conclusion need not be the one supplied by the hypothesis for the same . The statement asserts only that some guard in meets both requirements at once.
Degenerate cases.
- Empty guard set. The carrier is never empty, so never satisfies hypothesis 3. The statement therefore says nothing about empty .
- No edges (). The hypotheses force . The conclusion then reduces to two facts, both of which hold: sees itself, because , and .
- Collinear and vertical edges. Distinctness of the vertices excludes zero-length edges. Consecutive collinear edges and vertical edges are permitted by the hypotheses.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.