Observation 4, p. 8775 — φ(P_A(A)) = P_C(C) iff A ~ C, > iff A ≻ C, < iff A ≺ C
ProvedSourceTheory.InsensMatch.observation_4ambiguitydecision-theoryp2o-batch-pfp2ap2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1pmatcher
Assume structural Assumption 1 and Assumption 2 for sources and , and let be a transformation with on (the pmatcher from to ). Then for every and :
- if and only if , i.e. ;
- if and only if , i.e. ;
- if and only if , i.e. .
The pmatcher thus translates comparisons of events across sources into comparisons of probabilities, which is how the preference conditions of Definitions 2 and 4 become conditions on .
Formalization Note. Event preference is -order (Assumption 1: events are ranked via bets on them, maximizing ).
Preamble
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_SourceTheory_Uniform_Model
Formal statement
namespace SourceTheory.InsensMatch
open Set
/-- Observation 4 (p. 8775): for the pmatcher `φ` from `𝒜` to `𝒞`, `φ(P_𝒜(A)) = P_𝒞(C)` iff
`A ~ C`, `φ(P_𝒜(A)) > P_𝒞(C)` iff `A ≻ C`, and `φ(P_𝒜(A)) < P_𝒞(C)` iff `A ≺ C`. -/
theorem observation_4 {S Γ : Type*} (𝓔 : Set (Set S)) (pref : (S → Γ) → (S → Γ) → Prop)
(U : Γ → ℝ) (W : Set S → ℝ) (h1 : SourceTheory.Uniform.Assumption1 𝓔 pref U W)
(𝒜 𝒞 : Set (Set S)) (h𝒜 : SourceTheory.Uniform.IsSource 𝓔 W 𝒜) (h𝒞 : SourceTheory.Uniform.IsSource 𝓔 W 𝒞)
(PC PA : Set S → ℝ) (wC wA : ℝ → ℝ) (h2 : SourceTheory.Uniform.Assumption2 pref U W 𝒞 𝒜 PC PA wC wA)
(φ : ℝ → ℝ) (hφ : SourceTheory.Uniform.IsTransformation φ) (hφA : ∀ p ∈ Icc (0 : ℝ) 1, wA p = wC (φ p)) :
∀ A ∈ 𝒜, ∀ C ∈ 𝒞, (φ (PA A) = PC C ↔ W A = W C) ∧ (PC C < φ (PA A) ↔ W C < W A) ∧
(φ (PA A) < PC C ↔ W A < W C) := by sorry
end SourceTheory.InsensMatch
Source
Baillon et al. (2025), Management Science 71(10), Observation 4, p. 8775
Human review
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.