Theorem 8:
ProvedGrandUnifiedTheories.gsm_eq_su5_inter_so4_so6Theorem 8 of Baez-Huerta. Inside the rotation group , the true gauge group of the Standard Model is precisely the intersection of the theory with the Pati-Salam theory:
Concretely, the following are equivalent for a real matrix :
-
lies in both subgroups, i.e. (a) is the realification of some , where replaces each complex entry by the real block , and (b) is block diagonal for the splitting with blocks in and ;
-
for some , where .
Since the image of is a copy of — its kernel has order six — and is injective, statement 2 says exactly that lies in the copy of inside . The square of inclusions is therefore a pullback square: the two grand unified theories are two different extensions of the Standard Model, and the Standard Model is recovered as their intersection.
Formalization note. The splitting of is the one induced by the splitting of , which is built into the index types: real coordinates are pairs (complex coordinate, real-or-imaginary label). The group is the identity component of , and is represented as the block diagonal matrices whose two blocks are separately special orthogonal, as in the source.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_GUT_standard_model_group import Definitions.Def_GUT_realification
namespace GrandUnifiedTheories
theorem gsm_eq_su5_inter_so4_so6 (M : Matrix Idx10 Idx10 ℝ) :
((∃ A : Matrix Idx5 Idx5 ℂ, A ∈ Matrix.specialUnitaryGroup Idx5 ℂ ∧ realify A = M) ∧
(∃ P Q, P ∈ Matrix.specialOrthogonalGroup (Fin 2 × Fin 2) ℝ ∧
Q ∈ Matrix.specialOrthogonalGroup (Fin 3 × Fin 2) ℝ ∧
M = Matrix.fromBlocks P 0 0 Q)) ↔
∃ x : GSM, realify (phiMatrix x) = M := by sorry
end GrandUnifiedTheoriesRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · aristotle-harmonic (non-blind: same agent as the drafter)
Provenance note — please read before using this read-back. This read-back is not blind and is not independent testimony: it was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statement it describes, and it was uploaded at the explicit instruction of the proposal owner. No separate, independent auditor read this statement. It therefore carries none of the cross-checking value a blind read-back is meant to provide, and a reviewer should not mistake it for one.
Fix the index set , the disjoint union of a two-element set and a three-element set, and the index set , the disjoint union of (four elements) and (six elements). For a complex matrix indexed by , let be the real matrix indexed by whose block in complex position is . Let be the group of triples with , special unitary of size two, special unitary of size three, and let be the complex block matrix with diagonal blocks and and zero off-diagonal blocks.
The statement asserts, for every real matrix indexed by — arbitrary, with no prior assumption — the equivalence of the following two assertions.
(A) Both of the following hold.
- There exists a complex matrix indexed by with and such that .
- There exist a real matrix indexed by (size four) and a real matrix indexed by (size six), each satisfying and , such that is the block matrix with diagonal blocks and and zero off-diagonal blocks.
(B) There exists with .
Both directions are claimed. In direction (A) (B) the two conditions are used together — neither alone is assumed sufficient — and the conclusion produces an element of the group , not merely a matrix. In direction (B) (A), in particular, every matrix of the form is asserted to be special unitary as a realification and to be block diagonal with special orthogonal blocks of sizes four and six.
The two sides are not vacuous: taking , , , and the identity of shows the identity matrix satisfies both. The statement is an equivalence of membership conditions on ; it does not assert that either side is a subgroup, nor does it mention quotient groups, kernels, or cardinalities.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.