Lemma 6.1.4 — likelihood-ratio monotonicity of the binomial filter update
ProvedMDPFinance.POMDPFinance.lemma_6_1_4For the binomial market with unknown up-probability , this lemma records the two facts
that drive every subsequent monotonicity result of the section. (a) A single down-move followed
by an up-move produces a more favorable posterior than a single down-move alone: in terms of the
explicit sufficient-statistic update, , i.e. observing one more up-move (holding the trial count fixed) shifts the posterior up in
the likelihood-ratio order. (b) The belief-only value function (MDPFinance.POMDPFinance. dPow) is monotone in the likelihood-ratio order on reachable posteriors:
implies for every .
Formalization Note. Part (a) is stated directly on the explicit posterior-density formula
(binomialPosteriorDensity)
rather than through the general filter update , since it is exactly this closed form the
book's own proof inspects. Part (b) is stated for arbitrary densities p, p' in
satisfying the likelihood-ratio hypothesis, turned into measures via measureOfDensity
(Lebesgue density on ), matching the general statement's own universal
quantification over .
Moderation note. Stated for the binomial market (IsBinomialMarket), a prior density , and ; part a) is the likelihood ratio order of the two Bayes updates , of the filter (LRMeasure), part b) is for the recursion (6.4) dBin on normalized posteriors. The draft's part b) quantified over an arbitrary filter market and used unnormalized posterior densities, for which the claim is false.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_MDPFinance_POMDPFinance_Filter import Definitions.Def_MDPFinance_POMDPFinance_Binomial import Definitions.Def_MDPFinance_POMDPFinance_PowerLogValue open MeasureTheory ProbabilityTheory
namespace MDPFinance.POMDPFinance
/-- Lemma 6.1.4 (Bäuerle–Rieder, p. 179, PDF 192), for the binomial market with unknown
up-probability `θ \in Θ = (0,1)` (`IsBinomialMarket`: constant hidden parameter, returns `\bar u`
w.p. `θ`, `\bar d` w.p. `1-θ`), prior density `p_0`, up/down factors `0 < d < 1+i < u`,
`\bar u := u/(1+i) - 1`, `\bar d := d/(1+i) - 1`, power utility with `0 < γ < 1` (the subsection's
standing case). For `ρ = \hat μ(\cdot\mid m,n) \in D_{Q_0}` it holds: a) `Φ(ρ,\bar d) \le_{lr}
Φ(ρ,\bar u)`, the likelihood ratio order (Definition B.3.5) of the two Bayes updates of the
filter `Φ` (which, by `FilterOp.hPhi` at the binomial market, are `\hat μ(\cdot\mid m,n+1)` and
`\hat μ(\cdot\mid m+1,n+1)`, the book's proof identity). b) `ρ \le_{lr} ρ' \Rightarrow d_k(\rho)
\le d_k(\rho')` for the binomial recursion (6.4) `dBin` (every `k`, matching the book's own
induction on `n`, restated with `k` = stages remaining; `ρ`, `ρ'` are posterior densities in
`D_{Q_0}`, turned into probability measures via `measureOfDensity`). -/
theorem lemma_6_1_4 (M : FilterMarket ℝ 1) (Fd : FilterOp M) (u dn i : ℝ) (hdn : 0 < dn)
(hd : dn < 1 + i) (hi : 1 + i < u) (hM : IsBinomialMarket M u dn i) (γ : ℝ) (hγ0 : 0 < γ)
(hγ1 : γ < 1) (p0 : ℝ → ℝ) (hp0 : IsPriorDensity p0) (m n : ℕ) (hmn : m ≤ n) :
LRMeasure (volume.restrict (Set.Ioo (0 : ℝ) 1))
(Fd.Phi (measureOfDensity (binomialPosteriorDensity p0 m n)) (dbar dn i))
(Fd.Phi (measureOfDensity (binomialPosteriorDensity p0 m n)) (ubar u i)) ∧
(∀ p p' : ℝ → ℝ, p ∈ DQ0 p0 → p' ∈ DQ0 p0 → LikelihoodRatioOrder p p' →
∀ k : ℕ, dBin M Fd u dn i γ k (measureOfDensity p) ≤
dBin M Fd u dn i γ k (measureOfDensity p')) := by sorry
end MDPFinance.POMDPFinance
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.