Full statement of the paper-completion goal
DefinitionLocalConjugacy_TargetsThe proposition PaperResults has one independently quantified field for each of Theorem 1.1, Lemma 1.2, Corollaries 1.3–1.4, Propositions 2.1–2.3, 3.1–3.2, and 4.1–4.2, plus both counterexamples. Constructing it proves all thirteen assertions. It supplies no field as an assumption of another field.
import Definitions.Def_LocalConjugacy_Examples
/-!
# Complete scope of the paper
Every field is one independently quantified assertion. No field assumes another
field, so this record asserts all results and both counterexamples together.
The fields repeat the public milestone statements exactly. This record is a goal
specification, not an axiom or a supplied proof of any of its components.
-/
universe u v
namespace LocalConjugacy
/-- The eleven numbered results and two unnumbered counterexamples. -/
structure PaperResults : Prop where
/-- Theorem 1.1: no finiteness or bounded nilpotency-class hypothesis is imposed on N. The supplements and the normal pronilpotent subgroup are closed. -/
theorem_1_1 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} (N H K : Subgroup G) [N.Normal]
(hN : IsClosed (N : Set G)) (hH : IsClosed (H : Set G))
(hK : IsClosed (K : Set G)) (hpron : Pronilpotent N)
(hcase : Prosupersolvable G ∨ Pronilpotent (G ⧸ N))
(hHN : Supplements N H) (hKN : Supplements N K) :
Conjugate H K ↔ LocallyConjugate H K
/-- Lemma 1.2: the simultaneous restriction map on actual H¹ classes is a pointed bijection to the full product of stable classes. N is finite and nilpotent. -/
lemma_1_2 {J : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} {N : Type v} [Group N]
[TopologicalSpace N] [MulDistribMulAction J N] [DiscreteTopology N] [Finite N] [Group.IsNilpotent N]
[ContinuousSMul J N]
(hcase : Prosupersolvable (ActionProduct J N) ∨ Pronilpotent J)
(P : PrimeDivisor J → Subgroup J) (hP : ∀ p, IsSylowPro p.val.val ⊤ (P p)) :
Function.Bijective (primaryRestriction (N := N) P) ∧
(primaryRestriction (N := N) P) default = default
/-- Corollary 1.3: an internal complement models the profinite semidirect product. Normality of N ∩ H is required inside N, and local witnesses may vary with p. -/
corollary_1_3 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} (N J H : Subgroup G)
(hN : IsClosed (N : Set G)) (hJ : IsClosed (J : Set G))
(hH : IsClosed (H : Set G)) (hsplit : Splits N J)
(hpron : Pronilpotent N) (hcase : Prosupersolvable G ∨ Pronilpotent J)
(hnormal : IntersectionNormal N H) (hlocal : LocallyContains H J) :
∃ g : G, conjugate g J ≤ H
/-- Corollary 1.4: Ω is nonempty and carries no topology. The action is transitive and its point stabilizers are closed; the local fixed points may depend on p. -/
corollary_1_4 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} {Ω : Type v} [MulAction G Ω] [Nonempty Ω]
(N J : Subgroup G) (hN : IsClosed (N : Set G)) (hJ : IsClosed (J : Set G))
(hsplit : Splits N J) (hpron : Pronilpotent N)
(hcase : Prosupersolvable G ∨ Pronilpotent J)
(htrans : MulAction.IsPretransitive G Ω)
(hclosed : ∀ x : Ω, IsClosed (MulAction.stabilizer G x : Set G))
(hnormal : ∃ x : Ω, IntersectionNormal N (MulAction.stabilizer G x))
(hlocal : SylowFixedPoints (Ω := Ω) J) : HasFixedPoint (Ω := Ω) J
/-- Proposition 2.1: discrete coefficients may be infinite but are locally finite. The new cocycle is fixed literally by Q and is trivial on J₀ ∩ Q. -/
proposition_2_1 {J : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} {N : Type v} [Group N]
[TopologicalSpace N] [MulDistribMulAction J N] [IsTopologicalGroup N] [DiscreteTopology N]
[ContinuousSMul J N] (hfinite : LocallyFiniteGroup N) (p p₀ : ℕ) (hp : p.Prime) (hp₀ : p₀.Prime) (hne : p₀ ≠ p)
(hN : IsPGroup p N) (J₀ Q : Subgroup J) [J₀.Normal]
(hJ₀ : IsClosed (J₀ : Set J)) (hQ : IsClosed (Q : Set J))
(hcyclic : Procyclic Q) (hpro : IsProP p₀ Q)
(f : Cocycle (N := N) J₀) (hinv : InvariantUnder Q J₀ f) :
∃ g : Cocycle (N := N) J₀, Cohomologous f g ∧
(∀ (q : J) (hq : q ∈ Q) (x : J) (hx : x ∈ J₀)
(hqx : q⁻¹ * x * q ∈ J₀),
q • g.toFun ⟨q⁻¹ * x * q, hqx⟩ = g.toFun ⟨x, hx⟩) ∧
∀ (q : J) (hq : q ∈ Q) (hq₀ : q ∈ J₀), g.toFun ⟨q, hq₀⟩ = 1
/-- Proposition 2.2: restriction at a closed normal subgroup of prime index is a pointed bijection onto stable classes, with locally finite coefficients. -/
proposition_2_2 {J : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} {N : Type v} [Group N]
[TopologicalSpace N] [MulDistribMulAction J N] [IsTopologicalGroup N] [DiscreteTopology N]
[ContinuousSMul J N] (hfinite : LocallyFiniteGroup N) (p p₀ : ℕ) (hp : p.Prime) (hp₀ : p₀.Prime) (hne : p₀ ≠ p)
(hJ : Prosolvable J) (hN : IsPGroup p N) (J₀ : Subgroup J) [J₀.Normal]
(hJ₀ : IsClosed (J₀ : Set J)) (hindex : J₀.index = p₀) :
Function.Bijective (stableRestriction (N := N) J₀) ∧
(stableRestriction (N := N) J₀) default = default
/-- Proposition 2.3: the arXiv version assumes profinite J and prosupersolvable NJ. There is no additional prosolvability hypothesis. Q is any Hall subgroup for the primes at most p, and the codomain is all H¹(Q,N), not just stable classes. -/
proposition_2_3 {J : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} {N : Type v} [Group N]
[TopologicalSpace N] [MulDistribMulAction J N] [DiscreteTopology N] [Finite N]
[ContinuousSMul J N] (p : ℕ) (hp : p.Prime) (hN : IsPGroup p N)
(hG : Prosupersolvable (ActionProduct J N))
(Q : Subgroup J) (hQ : IsHallPro {r | r ≤ p} Q) :
Function.Bijective (restrictH1 (N := N) (show Q ≤ ⊤ from le_top)) ∧
(restrictH1 (N := N) (show Q ≤ ⊤ from le_top)) default = default
/-- Proposition 3.1: in the arXiv version N is finite. Both H and K are actual complements, expressed with Mathlib’s standard subgroup complement predicate. -/
proposition_3_1 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} (N H K : Subgroup G) [N.Normal] [Finite N]
(hN : IsClosed (N : Set G)) (hH : IsClosed (H : Set G))
(hK : IsClosed (K : Set G)) (hpron : Pronilpotent N)
(hcase : Prosupersolvable G ∨ Pronilpotent (G ⧸ N))
(hNH : N.IsComplement' H) (hNK : N.IsComplement' K) :
Conjugate H K ↔ LocallyConjugate H K
/-- Proposition 3.2: the complete statement of Theorem 1.1 with finite N. The ambient profinite group G is not assumed finite. -/
proposition_3_2 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} (N H K : Subgroup G) [N.Normal] [Finite N]
(hN : IsClosed (N : Set G)) (hH : IsClosed (H : Set G))
(hK : IsClosed (K : Set G)) (hpron : Pronilpotent N)
(hcase : Prosupersolvable G ∨ Pronilpotent (G ⧸ N))
(hHN : Supplements N H) (hKN : Supplements N K) :
Conjugate H K ↔ LocallyConjugate H K
/-- Proposition 4.1: the abelian subgroup N and both supplements are closed. No solvability assumption is made on G. -/
proposition_4_1 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} (N H K : Subgroup G) [N.Normal]
(hN : IsClosed (N : Set G)) (hH : IsClosed (H : Set G))
(hK : IsClosed (K : Set G)) [IsMulCommutative N]
(hHN : Supplements N H) (hKN : Supplements N K)
(hlocal : LocallyContains H K) : ∃ g : G, conjugate g K ≤ H
/-- Proposition 4.2: an arbitrary transitive action on a nonempty set, with closed stabilizers. The abelian normal subgroup need not act transitively. -/
proposition_4_2 {G : ProfiniteGrp.{u}} {Ω : Type v} [MulAction G Ω] [Nonempty Ω]
(N H : Subgroup G) [N.Normal] (hN : IsClosed (N : Set G))
(hH : IsClosed (H : Set G)) [IsMulCommutative N]
(hHN : Supplements N H) (htrans : MulAction.IsPretransitive G Ω)
(hclosed : ∀ x : Ω, IsClosed (MulAction.stabilizer G x : Set G))
(hlocal : SylowFixedPoints (Ω := Ω) H) : HasFixedPoint (Ω := Ω) H
/-- First unnumbered counterexample, §1, p. 2. The matrix-group identification, cohomology cardinalities, and failure of conjugacy are all asserted together. -/
counterexample_quaternion :
∃ a : S3 →* MulAut Q8,
-- The action is realized in the matrix group named in the source.
Nonempty ((Q8 ⋊[a] S3) ≃* GL (Fin 2) (ZMod 3)) ∧
-- There are exactly two global cohomology classes.
Nat.card (FiniteH1 a) = 2 ∧
-- Every Sylow restriction has trivial first cohomology.
(∀ (p : ℕ) (hp : p.Prime),
letI : Fact p.Prime := ⟨hp⟩
∀ P : Sylow p S3, Subsingleton (FiniteH1 (a.comp P.toSubgroup.subtype))) ∧
-- The same action gives the locally conjugate, nonconjugate complements.
∃ J' : Subgroup (Q8 ⋊[a] S3),
(quaternionKernel a).IsComplement' J' ∧
FiniteLocallyConjugate (quaternionComplement a) J' ∧
¬ Conjugate (quaternionComplement a) J'
/-- Second unnumbered counterexample, §1, p. 2. The Heisenberg and wreath-product identifications are included explicitly, along with every stated local/global property. -/
counterexample_heisenberg :
∃ (G : ProfiniteGrp.{0}) (N J H : Subgroup G),
-- All concrete group identifications in the source are part of the target.
Finite G ∧ Nonempty (G ≃* WreathC3S3) ∧
Nonempty (N ≃* Heisenberg3) ∧
Nonempty (J ≃* Multiplicative (ZMod 6)) ∧
Nonempty (H ≃* C3 × S3) ∧
Nat.card G = 162 ∧ Nat.card N = 27 ∧ Nat.card J = 6 ∧ Nat.card H = 18 ∧
-- N and J form the specified internal semidirect product.
Splits N J ∧ Group.IsNilpotent N ∧ Group.IsNilpotent J ∧ Supersolvable G ∧
IsClosed (N : Set G) ∧ IsClosed (J : Set G) ∧ IsClosed (H : Set G) ∧
-- The local inclusion test succeeds, but global inclusion fails.
LocallyContains H J ∧ (¬ ∃ g : G, conjugate g J ≤ H) ∧
¬ IntersectionNormal N H
end LocalConjugacy
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · GPT-6 family (exact model variant not exposed)
PaperResults. For fixed universes , this defines a proposition-valued structure with the thirteen fields described below; an inhabitant supplies all thirteen assertions, and the declaration alone does not supply an inhabitant. Each universally quantified profinite group below has underlying type in universe , and each coefficient group or action set explicitly introduced as a type has underlying type in universe , except that the profinite group existentially quantified in the last field has underlying type in universe . A profinite group is a compact Hausdorff totally disconnected topological group. The following definitions specify the meanings of the custom predicates used throughout this paragraph. A group is called supersolvable here precisely when there are and a monotone sequence of subgroups of with , , every normal in , and, for every , an element with , where denotes the subgroup generated by the two subgroups and consists of the integer powers of . The value is included. A topological group is called pronilpotent, prosupersolvable, or prosolvable here when every quotient by an open normal subgroup is, respectively, nilpotent, supersolvable in the preceding sense, or solvable. A group is a -group when every element has for some ; a topological group is pro- when all its open normal quotients are -groups. For subgroups of a topological group , a Sylow pro- subgroup of means that , is closed in , is pro- with its induced topology, and every closed pro- subgroup containing equals . Subgroups are conjugate when for some , and are locally conjugate when, for each prime natural number , there exist Sylow pro- subgroups of and of and with . The assertion that locally contains means that for each prime there are a Sylow pro- subgroup of and with . The assertion that supplements means that every can be written with and . The assertion that splits as means that is normal in and that every has exactly one expression with . The intersection-normality assertion for means that , regarded as a subgroup of , is normal in . For an action on a set , a subgroup has a fixed point when some is fixed by all its elements; its Sylow fixed-point condition means that for every prime there is a Sylow pro- subgroup of it having a fixed point, with the subgroup and point allowed to depend on . For the cohomological assertions, if a topological group acts on a topological group by multiplicative automorphisms, a continuous cocycle on is a continuous function satisfying for all . Write for these functions modulo the equivalence relation defined by the existence of one with for all , and let its distinguished element be the class of the constant function . Write for the subset of consisting of classes with a representative such that, for every , there is for which for every whose conjugate also lies in . The element may depend on but must work for all such ; this condition places no constraint at when its conjugate lies outside , and its distinguished element is again the class of the constant cocycle. Restriction means the map on these quotient classes induced by restricting a representative function. In particular is restriction with this codomain, where denotes the whole subgroup of itself. Let be the set of primes dividing the natural-number cardinality of for at least one open normal subgroup of . For a family indexed by , primary restriction is the map whose -coordinate is restriction to , and the product's distinguished element has every coordinate distinguished. If is empty, this product has exactly one element. The action semidirect product used below has product and the topology transported from the product topology on . The thirteen fields are as follows. theorem_1_1: For every profinite group and subgroups , assume that is normal, that are closed, that is pronilpotent, that either is prosupersolvable or is pronilpotent, and that both and supplement . Then and are conjugate in if and only if they are locally conjugate in the sense specified above. lemma_1_2: For every profinite group and group equipped with a discrete topology, assume that is finite and nilpotent, that has an action on by multiplicative automorphisms whose joint action map is continuous, and that either with the product topology is prosupersolvable or is pronilpotent. For every family of subgroups indexed by such that each is a Sylow pro- subgroup of all of , primary restriction is bijective and maps the distinguished class to the distinguished tuple. There is no nonemptiness assumption on . corollary_1_3: For every profinite group and closed subgroups , assume that splits as , that is pronilpotent, that either is prosupersolvable or is pronilpotent, that is normal in , and that locally contains . Then there exists with . corollary_1_4: For every profinite group , nonempty set , and group action of on , and for every pair of closed subgroups , assume that splits as , that is pronilpotent, that either is prosupersolvable or is pronilpotent, that the -action is transitive (for every some satisfies ), that every stabilizer is closed in , that there exists for which is normal in , and that satisfies the Sylow fixed-point condition. Then some point of is fixed by every element of . No topology on or continuity assumption on the action is supplied. proposition_2_1: For every profinite group and discrete topological group , assume a jointly continuous action of on by multiplicative automorphisms and assume that every finite subset of generates a finite subgroup. For every pair of natural numbers that are prime and satisfy , assume that is a -group. For every pair of subgroups , assume that is normal and closed in , that is closed in , that some element of has its subgroup of integer powers dense in , and that is pro-. For every continuous cocycle satisfying the following invariance condition: for each there exists with for every (with the required membership ), there exists a continuous cocycle such that for every for one , such that for every and and every supplied membership , and such that for every . Normality of ensures these conjugate-membership conditions for all the indicated . No finiteness assumption on is imposed beyond finite generation from a finite subset giving a finite subgroup. proposition_2_2: For every profinite group and discrete topological group , assume a jointly continuous action of on by multiplicative automorphisms and assume that every finite subset of generates a finite subgroup. For every pair of prime natural numbers with , assume that is prosolvable and is a -group. For every closed normal subgroup whose subgroup index in is exactly , the restriction map is bijective and sends the distinguished element to the distinguished element. proposition_2_3: For every profinite group and finite group with a discrete topology and a jointly continuous action of on by multiplicative automorphisms, for every prime natural number , assume that is a -group and that with the product topology is prosupersolvable. For every subgroup , assume that is closed and that, for every open normal subgroup , each prime divisor of the cardinality of the image of in is at most , while each prime divisor of the index of that image in is strictly greater than . Then restriction is bijective and maps the distinguished element to the distinguished element. These prime-divisor conditions impose no requirement that itself occur as a divisor. proposition_3_1: For every profinite group and subgroups , assume that is normal and finite, that are closed, that is pronilpotent, that either is prosupersolvable or is pronilpotent, that every has exactly one expression with , and that every has exactly one expression with . Then and are conjugate in if and only if they are locally conjugate. proposition_3_2: For every profinite group and subgroups , assume that is normal and finite, that are closed, that is pronilpotent, that either is prosupersolvable or is pronilpotent, and that both and supplement . Then and are conjugate in if and only if they are locally conjugate. proposition_4_1: For every profinite group and subgroups , assume that is normal and commutative, that are closed, that both and supplement , and that locally contains . Then there exists with . proposition_4_2: For every profinite group , nonempty set , and group action of on , and for every pair of subgroups , assume that is normal and commutative, that are closed, that supplements , that the action is transitive, that every stabilizer is closed in , and that satisfies the Sylow fixed-point condition. Then some point of is fixed by every element of . No topology on or continuity assumption on its action is supplied. counterexample_quaternion: There exists a group homomorphism , where is the permutation group of and is the eight-element quaternion group, satisfying all of the following. The abstract group , with product , is isomorphic as a group to the group of invertible matrices over . The quotient set of all functions satisfying , modulo for some single and every , has natural-number cardinality exactly . For every prime natural number and every Sylow -subgroup of , the analogous quotient set for the restricted action of on has at most one element; the constant cocycle in fact supplies an element of each such quotient. Here Sylow means maximal among -subgroups, and these quantifiers include primes not dividing . There also exists a subgroup such that multiplication from to the ambient group is bijective, where , and such that and have conjugate Sylow -subgroups in the ambient group for every prime , but no element of the ambient group conjugates to . In the local condition, for each prime one may choose a Sylow subgroup of , a Sylow subgroup of , and a conjugating element separately; all cohomology sets in this field use arbitrary cocycle functions without topology or continuity requirements. counterexample_heisenberg: There exist a profinite group with underlying type in universe and subgroups such that is finite and such that abstract group isomorphisms exist from to , from to the group of triples with product , from to the additive group of written multiplicatively, and from to . Here is the additive group of written multiplicatively, permutes , the function group has pointwise multiplication, and the semidirect action is . Moreover the natural-number cardinalities satisfy , , , and ; is normal in and every element of has exactly one expression with ; both and are nilpotent groups; is supersolvable in the finite-normal-sequence sense defined above; and are closed in . For every prime there exist a Sylow pro- subgroup of and with , but there is no with , and is not normal as a subgroup of . The group isomorphisms asserted in this field and the quaternion field are multiplicative isomorphisms; no topological-isomorphism data are requested. Apart from the explicit nonemptiness assumptions on the action sets, the universal assertions above allow trivial groups and subgroups, include every prime rather than only primes dividing the ambient group, and impose no additional nontriviality hypotheses.
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.