Prop. 2.2 remark: the gauge freedom of the recovered pair
ProvedNewtonCartan.gauge_iffSpacetime is in a global chart (index 0 = time) with , ; a derivative operator is a smooth symmetric Christoffel field ; curvature in Malament's convention , ; is the geometrization; timelike curves have unit tangent . If satisfies the conclusion of Prop. 2.2 for , then another pair does iff satisfies and , i.e. .
import Definitions.Def_NewtonCartan_defs open scoped ContDiff
namespace NewtonCartan
/-- **Non-uniqueness in Prop. 2.2 (Weatherall p. 5; Malament Prop. 4.2.5).** If `(φ, ∇)` satisfies the
conclusion of Prop. 2.2 for `(∇̃, ρ)`, then a second pair `(φ', ∇')` satisfies the same conditions
iff `ψ = φ' - φ` obeys `∇^a ∇^b ψ = 0` and `∇' = (∇, t_b t_c ∇^a ψ)`. -/
theorem gauge_iff (Γt Γ Γ' : Conn) (φ φ' ρ : E → ℝ) (hΓt : IsClassical Γt)
(hNG : IsNG Γ φ) (hT : SameTrajectories Γ φ Γt) (hP : Poisson Γ φ ρ) :
(IsNG Γ' φ' ∧ SameTrajectories Γ' φ' Γt ∧ Poisson Γ' φ' ρ) ↔
(IsGauge Γ (fun x => φ' x - φ x) ∧ Γ' = gaugeΓ Γ (fun x => φ' x - φ x)) := by sorry
end NewtonCartanRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5
For connections and functions , assume classical, classical, flat, , SameTrajectories(), and Poisson(). Then: [ classical, flat, , SameTrajectories() and Poisson()] holds iff [with : , (w.r.t. ) everywhere, and ].
Flags: satisfiable hypotheses; is only linked via Poisson. Both directions checked informally: (->) uses uniqueness in geometrization () and flatness of both giving vanishing spatial Hessian of ; (<-) uses , . Appears true. Sign: , whereas the docstring writes (notation issue as above). The gauge condition constrains only spatial Hessian components, not .
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.