Idealized Hubble's law
ProvedHubbleLaw.idealized_hubble_lawIdealized Hubble's law. The source states the geometric content of Hubble's law as follows: any two points which are moving away from the origin, each along straight lines and with speed proportional to distance from the origin, will be moving away from each other with a speed proportional to their distance apart.
Formally, work in three-dimensional Euclidean space, fix a time and a proportionality constant , and let be the trajectories of two points. The hypothesis "moving away from the origin along a straight line with speed proportional to the distance from the origin, with constant " is the statement that the velocity of each point at time is times its position vector:
Then the separation vector is differentiable at with
so the relative velocity is parallel to the separation, and its magnitude is
that is, times the distance between the two points. Because is the same constant for every pair of points, every observer in such an expansion sees the same law, and no point is a distinguished centre of the expansion.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_HubbleLawDefs
namespace HubbleLaw
theorem idealized_hubble_law (H t : ℝ) (hH : 0 ≤ H)
(p q : ℝ → EuclideanSpace ℝ (Fin 3))
(hp : HasDerivAt p (H • p t) t) (hq : HasDerivAt q (H • q t) t) :
HasDerivAt (fun s => p s - q s) (H • (p t - q t)) t ∧
‖H • (p t - q t)‖ = H * ‖p t - q t‖ := by sorry
end HubbleLawRead-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic) — NOT an independent auditor: same agent that drafted the statements
Disclosure — this read-back is NOT independent testimony. It was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statements in this proposal, at the explicit instruction of the proposal owner. It is not blind: its author knew what each statement was intended to say before writing the read-back, so it cannot corroborate the formalization the way an independent auditor's read-back would. Please read it as the drafter's own restatement of the code, and audit the Lean text directly (or commission a blind read-back) before relying on it.
Fix two real numbers and , with the single assumption , and two arbitrary functions , where carries the Euclidean () norm. No continuity, differentiability or other regularity of and is assumed at any point other than the single time , and nothing is assumed about the values of and elsewhere.
The two hypotheses are derivative statements at the one point :
where is scalar multiplication of a vector. Both hypotheses use the same scalar . They are conditions only at ; they do not say that for other .
The conclusion is a conjunction of two claims.
First claim. The function has derivative
at the point .
Second claim. The norm identity
holds. This second claim is a statement about the vector and the scalar only: it does not mention derivatives, and it would hold for any vector and any regardless of the two hypotheses. It is stated in terms of the derivative value from the first claim rather than in terms of a separately quantified velocity.
Degenerate cases included by the quantifiers: (both claims then say that the separation has zero derivative and zero speed); , i.e. two points at the same place, where both sides of the norm identity are ; and . The hypothesis allows but excludes contraction, ; for negative the second claim would fail as stated, since the left-hand side is .
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.