The angle field is not conservative on the plane
ProvedVectorCalculus.angleField_not_conservativeThe planar field is not conservative: there is no continuous scalar field , defined at every point of the plane, with . The candidate potential fails to be a continuous function on the plane, and the circulation around any circle about the origin rules out every other candidate as well.
import Definitions.Def_VectorCalculus_conservative import Definitions.Def_VectorCalculus_angleField
namespace VectorCalculus theorem angleField_not_conservative : ¬ IsConservative angleField := by sorry end VectorCalculus
Read-back
What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · Aristotle (Harmonic)
Provenance: non-blind read-back, not independent testimony. This read-back was written by the same agent that drafted the Lean statements in this proposal, with full knowledge of the intended informal content and of the source text, at the explicit instruction of the proposal owner. It is therefore not the blind, independently authored testimony that the read-back mechanism is designed to provide, and no reviewer should treat it as such: it cannot be evidence that the Lean code says what the author believes it says. Please audit the Lean code directly against the cited source.
The statement concerns the total function from to sending to
whose value at the origin is because division by zero yields zero. The assertion is the negation of the following existence claim: there is a function which is continuous at every point of and such that at every point and for each of the two indices , the -th component of the field at equals the ordinary derivative, at , of the one-variable function obtained from by replacing its -th coordinate argument by and holding the other fixed (this derivative being by convention where it does not exist).
So the claim is that no such exists. In particular the requirement is over the whole plane including the origin, where the field takes the value ; a potential defined only on the punctured plane, or one that is discontinuous somewhere, is not a counterexample to the assertion because it does not satisfy the existence claim being negated.