Proposition 9 — (P-Compactness) and (P-USC) imply a primal optimizer exists
ProvedModelRiskOT.PrimalOpt.proposition_9Let be a Polish space, a probability measure on , , and let and satisfy (A1) and (A2). Assume the standing assumption of §5: is a dual optimal pair with
If has Property (P-Compactness) at and Property (P-USC), then there is a primal optimizer with
The primal feasible set is in general not weakly compact, and the supremum need not be attained (Example 2 of the paper); the two properties replace compactness and upper semicontinuity.
Formalization Note The equality is Theorem 1(a) of the paper, which is not assumed proved here; it enters as the hypothesis of the section's standing assumption, together with the dual optimality and finiteness. No sign condition on beyond (part of ) is assumed.
import Mathlib import Definitions.Def_ModelRiskOT_PrimalOpt_PCompactness import Definitions.Def_ModelRiskOT_PrimalOpt_PUSC
namespace ModelRiskOT.PrimalOpt
open MeasureTheory
/-- **Proposition 9** (§5, p. 26). Assume (A1), (A2) and the standing assumption of §5:
`(λ*, φ_{λ*}) ∈ Λ_{c,f}` is a dual optimal pair with `I = J = J(λ*, φ_{λ*}) < ∞` (the identity
`I = J` is Theorem 1(a), taken here as a hypothesis). If (P-Compactness) holds for `λ*` and (P-USC)
holds, there is a primal optimizer `π* ∈ Φ_{μ,δ}` with `I(π*) = I = J = J(λ*, φ_{λ*})`. -/
theorem proposition_9 {S : Type*} [TopologicalSpace S] [PolishSpace S] [MeasurableSpace S]
[BorelSpace S] (c : S → S → ℝ) (f : S → ℝ) (μ : Measure S) [IsProbabilityMeasure μ]
(δ : ℝ) (hδ : 0 < δ) (hA1 : ModelRiskOT.Duality.AssumptionA1 c) (hA2 : AssumptionA2 f μ)
(lam : ℝ) (hfeas : (lam, phiLam c f lam) ∈ dualFeasible c f)
(hIJ : ModelRiskOT.Duality.primalValue c f μ δ = ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualValue c f μ δ)
(hopt : ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualValue c f μ δ = ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualObj μ δ lam (phiLam c f lam))
(hfin : ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualObj μ δ lam (phiLam c f lam) < ⊤)
(hP1 : PCompactness c f μ lam) (hP2 : PUSC c f μ δ) :
∃ πstar ∈ ModelRiskOT.Duality.primalFeasible c μ δ,
ModelRiskOT.Duality.primalObj f πstar = ModelRiskOT.Duality.primalValue c f μ δ ∧ ModelRiskOT.Duality.primalValue c f μ δ = ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualValue c f μ δ ∧
ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualValue c f μ δ = ModelRiskOT.Duality.dualObj μ δ lam (phiLam c f lam) := by sorry
end ModelRiskOT.PrimalOpt
Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).
Confirmed by the moderator at approval.