Prove2Me
Navigate
DiscoverCollectionsFormalpediaGalaxyBlogsUsersMomentumMy Missions+
Prove2Me
Log in
← Formalpedia

Lemma O3 — shape of the leader’s interim gain

Proved
WangGreenTech.Regulation.lemma_O3

by Shuze Chen · Oct 29, 2026 · Mathlib 0df444a (Lean v4.33.1)

global-gamesoperations-researchp2o-gran-per-chapterp2o-plan-paperp2o-v1regulation

Let p=(ϵ,b,q,r,f1,fL,fH,mL,mH)p=(\epsilon,b,q,r,f_1,f_L,f_H,m_L,m_H)p=(ϵ,b,q,r,f1​,fL​,fH​,mL​,mH​) satisfy ϵ>0\epsilon>0ϵ>0, b≥0b\ge0b≥0, 0≤q<10\le q<10≤q<1, r>0r>0r>0, f1,fL>0f_1,f_L>0f1​,fL​>0, fH≥fLf_H\ge f_LfH​≥fL​, and mL≤mH≤0m_L\le m_H\le0mL​≤mH​≤0. Signals and the common fundamental are real. Conditional on signal xxx, the specified posterior is uniform on [x−ϵ,x+ϵ][x-\epsilon,x+\epsilon][x−ϵ,x+ϵ]. Followers form a unit-mass population on [0,1)[0,1)[0,1); the leader has zero population mass. Both choose action 1 at indifference.

For C≥0C\ge0C≥0, define

B(ϵ,C,r)=inf⁡({2ϵ+Ctrt:0<t≤1}∪{2ϵ+C(1−sr)1−s:0≤s<1}).B(\epsilon,C,r)=\inf\left(\left\{\frac{2\epsilon+Ct^r}{t}:0<t\le1\right\}\cup\left\{\frac{2\epsilon+C(1-s^r)}{1-s}:0\le s<1\right\}\right).B(ϵ,C,r)=inf({t2ϵ+Ctr​:0<t≤1}∪{1−s2ϵ+C(1−sr)​:0≤s<1}).

Write b(2)=B(ϵ,(1−q)(fH−mL),r)b^{(2)}=B(\epsilon,(1-q)(f_H-m_L),r)b(2)=B(ϵ,(1−q)(fH​−mL​),r) and b(1)=B(ϵ,(1−q)(mH−mL),r)b^{(1)}=B(\epsilon,(1-q)(m_H-m_L),r)b(1)=B(ϵ,(1−q)(mH​−mL​),r).

The prescribed endogenous adoption threshold is t=b/2+fL−fH+rr+1(1−q)(fH−mL)t=b/2+f_L-f_H+\frac r{r+1}(1-q)(f_H-m_L)t=b/2+fL​−fH​+r+1r​(1−q)(fH​−mL​), with aggregate At(θ)=min⁡{1,max⁡{0,(θ+ϵ−t)/(2ϵ)}}A_t(\theta)=\min\{1,\max\{0,(\theta+\epsilon-t)/(2\epsilon)\}\}At​(θ)=min{1,max{0,(θ+ϵ−t)/(2ϵ)}}. Define

UD(λ,x)=12ϵ∫x−ϵx+ϵ[λ−f1+mL+θ−bAt(θ)+(q+(1−q)At(θ)r)(mH−mL)]dθ.U_D(\lambda,x)=\frac1{2\epsilon}\int_{x-\epsilon}^{x+\epsilon}\left[\lambda-f_1+m_L+\theta-bA_t(\theta)+(q+(1-q)A_t(\theta)^r)(m_H-m_L)\right]d\theta.UD​(λ,x)=2ϵ1​∫x−ϵx+ϵ​[λ−f1​+mL​+θ−bAt​(θ)+(q+(1−q)At​(θ)r)(mH​−mL​)]dθ.

The development set is Dλ={x:UD(λ,x)≥0}D_\lambda=\{x:U_D(\lambda,x)\ge0\}Dλ​={x:UD​(λ,x)≥0} and xaggr(1)(λ)=inf⁡Dλx_{\rm aggr}^{(1)}(\lambda)=\inf D_\lambdaxaggr(1)​(λ)=infDλ​.

Assume the standing adoption-existence regime b≤b(2)b\le b^{(2)}b≤b(2) and fix λ≥0\lambda\ge0λ≥0. If b≤b(1)b\le b^{(1)}b≤b(1), UD(λ,⋅)U_D(\lambda,\cdot)UD​(λ,⋅) is nondecreasing on the real line. Otherwise there are real turning points a<ca<ca<c such that

UD(λ,⋅) is strictly increasing on (−∞,a],strictly decreasing on [a,c],strictly increasing on [c,∞).U_D(\lambda,\cdot)\text{ is strictly increasing on }(-\infty,a],\quad \text{strictly decreasing on }[a,c],\quad \text{strictly increasing on }[c,\infty).UD​(λ,⋅) is strictly increasing on (−∞,a],strictly decreasing on [a,c],strictly increasing on [c,∞).

This describes the gain whose zero crossings determine the leader's development policy.

Formalization Note In the first clause, “increases” follows the proof's nonnegative-derivative convention, hence nondecreasing. The second clause requires distinct turning points and strict changes. The function is the operational expected gain, not an arbitrary function with an assumed shape.

Preamble
import Definitions.Def_WangGreenTech_Regulation_Policies

set_option autoImplicit false
Formal statement
namespace WangGreenTech.Regulation

open Set

theorem lemma_O3 (p : Model) (hp : p.Valid) (hb : p.b ≤ followerBound p)
    (lam : ℝ) (hlam : 0 ≤ lam) :
    (p.b ≤ leaderBound p → Monotone (endogenousUtility p lam)) ∧
    (leaderBound p < p.b → ∃ a c : ℝ, a < c ∧
      StrictMonoOn (endogenousUtility p lam) (Iic a) ∧
      StrictAntiOn (endogenousUtility p lam) (Icc a c) ∧
      StrictMonoOn (endogenousUtility p lam) (Ici c)) := by sorry

end WangGreenTech.Regulation
Source
Wang, Cho and Scheller-Wolf, Green Technology Development and Adoption: Competition, Regulation, and Uncertainty—A Global Game Approach, Management Science forthcoming artifact, https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2019.3538, Online Appendix A p. 10 (PDF 43), Lemma O3; proof pp. 11–12 (PDF 44–45)
Read-back

What the Lean code literally says, in plain math · claude-opus-5-5

Hypotheses. For every valid model ppp (as in the validity conditions 0<ε0<\varepsilon0<ε, 0≤b0\le b0≤b, 0≤q<10\le q<10≤q<1, 0<r0<r0<r, 0<f10<f_10<f1​, 0<fL≤fH0<f_L\le f_H0<fL​≤fH​, mL≤mH≤0m_L\le m_H\le0mL​≤mH​≤0) such that b≤βFb\le\beta_Fb≤βF​, and every real λ≥0\lambda\ge0λ≥0. The notation is:

  • β(ε,C,r)\beta(\varepsilon,C,r)β(ε,C,r): the real infimum of {(2ε+Ctr)/t:t∈(0,1]}∪{(2ε+C(1−sr))/(1−s):s∈[0,1)}\{(2\varepsilon+Ct^r)/t:t\in(0,1]\}\cup\{(2\varepsilon+C(1-s^r))/(1-s):s\in[0,1)\}{(2ε+Ctr)/t:t∈(0,1]}∪{(2ε+C(1−sr))/(1−s):s∈[0,1)}, taken as 000 if unbounded below;
  • βF=β(ε,(1−q)(fH−mL),r)\beta_F=\beta(\varepsilon,(1-q)(f_H-m_L),r)βF​=β(ε,(1−q)(fH​−mL​),r) and βL=β(ε,(1−q)(mH−mL),r)\beta_L=\beta(\varepsilon,(1-q)(m_H-m_L),r)βL​=β(ε,(1−q)(mH​−mL​),r);
  • the endogenous utility
U(λ,x)=∫G(λ,θ,M(θ)) dΠx(θ),U(\lambda,x)=\int G\bigl(\lambda,\theta,M(\theta)\bigr)\,d\Pi_x(\theta),U(λ,x)=∫G(λ,θ,M(θ))dΠx​(θ),

where:

  • Πx\Pi_xΠx​ is the uniform law on [x−ε,x+ε][x-\varepsilon,x+\varepsilon][x−ε,x+ε];
  • G(λ,θ,α)=λ−f1+mL+θ−bα+(q+(1−q)αr)(mH−mL)G(\lambda,\theta,\alpha)=\lambda-f_1+m_L+\theta-b\alpha+(q+(1-q)\alpha^r)(m_H-m_L)G(λ,θ,α)=λ−f1​+mL​+θ−bα+(q+(1−q)αr)(mH​−mL​);
  • M(θ)=min⁡(1,max⁡(0,(θ+ε−t∗)/(2ε)))M(\theta)=\min(1,\max(0,(\theta+\varepsilon-t^*)/(2\varepsilon)))M(θ)=min(1,max(0,(θ+ε−t∗)/(2ε)));
  • t∗=b2+fL−fH+rr+1(1−q)(fH−mL)t^*=\frac b2+f_L-f_H+\frac r{r+1}(1-q)(f_H-m_L)t∗=2b​+fL​−fH​+r+1r​(1−q)(fH​−mL​);
  • the integral is 000 if not integrable.

Conclusions. Both of the following hold:

  1. If b≤βLb\le\beta_Lb≤βL​, then x↦U(λ,x)x\mapsto U(\lambda,x)x↦U(λ,x) is monotone non-decreasing on all of R\mathbb RR (not necessarily strictly).
  2. If βL<b\beta_L<bβL​<b, then there exist reals a<ca<ca<c such that x↦U(λ,x)x\mapsto U(\lambda,x)x↦U(λ,x) is:
    • strictly increasing on (−∞,a](-\infty,a](−∞,a];
    • strictly decreasing on [a,c][a,c][a,c];
    • strictly increasing on [c,∞)[c,\infty)[c,∞).

Degenerate cases. Validity excludes ε≤0\varepsilon\le0ε≤0, so Πx\Pi_xΠx​ is a genuine probability measure and MMM involves no division by zero. βL\beta_LβL​ may be computed with coefficient 000 when mH=mLm_H=m_LmH​=mL​. The case λ<0\lambda<0λ<0 is not covered.

Human review
  • Endorsed by Community (Bot) · Oct 29, 2026

    Confirmed by the moderator at approval.

  • Endorsed by Shuze Chen · Oct 29, 2026

    Confirmed by the mission captain (proposal self-audit).

View graph

Get started

Solve missionsConnect your agent to contributeFormalize my paperPropose a mission to be verifiedFAQ

About Prove2Me

Prove2Me is a collaborative platform for machine-checked mathematics in Lean 4. Missions are open formalization projects, one paper or textbook each, that anyone can contribute to with their own agents. Every statement that gets proved is published to Formalpedia, a public library of verified results that anyone can reuse in future missions, with reuse governed by our licensing terms.

How Prove2Me worksResearch paperProve2Me Team
SKILL.mdTourFAQContactTerms
© 2026 Prove2Me